The Tichborne Claimant

Reviews / Votes

Mentioned in History Today, July 2009 '[McWilliam] tells the story with a lucid command of narrative and an understated wit.' - London Review of Books 'McWilliam has done a wonderful, thoughtful and imaginative job, and in so doing has thrown up some welcome challenges to the way that we think about political and social history. His understanding of why the Tichborne story remains puzzling even after his painstaking reconstruction forces us to continue asking difficult questions about the connections between politics and emotion in an emerging mass culture.' - Journal of Victorian Culture, 2009 'Rohan McWilliam, a Senior Lecturer in History at Anglia Ruskin University, has produced a scholarly study of an extraordinary event in the nineteenth century which aroused great passion. The general reader will...enjoy the book for its logical exposition and balanced assessment.' - The Historical Association 'The Tichborne Claimant is a superb example of what a dedicated, sensitive historian can do in terms of opening up a vanished world. It is engaging written: despite pulling in a range of recent emphases in cultural history, it is never burdened by the theoretical weight of the work it accomplishes so handily.' - Media History, August 2008 -Mention. The Chronicle of Higher Education/ July 13, 2007 Reviewed by Emeritus Professor G.R. Batho, The Historical Association. "In each case an event or a figure that scholars had previously confined to passing references becomes a key to unlock the broadest possible understanding of their respective periods. Now, with Rohan McWilliam's rich book we can add the Tichborne imposture case to this (partial) list of episodes rescued from the indifference of posterity. But what makes this addition especially remarkable is the fact that the Tichborne story, unlike most others in this genre, is not simply an unnoticed backdoor key to the bigger picture. Rather, as McWilliam persuasively shows, it is itself the bigger picture." - Dror Wahrman, Victorian Studies, Winter 2008 -- Dror Wahrman 'In this well-research and well-written book, Rohan McWilliam has produced an entertaining and wide-ranging account of a case that aroused widespread interest in mid-Victorian Britain but that, at least until the 1998 film The Tichborne Claimant, scarcely gets more than passing reference today. It is one of the strengths of the book that it takes the reader beyond the narrow confines of the case itself and sets the claimant and his case in a broader sociopolitical and cultural context and in so doing brings out the wide significance of the popular movement that grew up around such an unlikely character.' - Journal of British Studies, 2008 'This book is a remarkable, fascinating study of Victorian popular politics that will interest many.' - American Historical Review, 2008 'The overall strength of the book is unmistakable. It does not just inform the reader about the Tichborne Claimant and the progress of his case until his final demise. It contextualizes it in the richness of its Victorian setting and comes as near to making sense of the whole nonsensical affair as could be achieved - and that turns it into a book which informs the reader about late Victorian British society, illuminating complex cultural agendas and often contradictory social rules, showing how these intersect and interact and how they affected popular understandings of many things. It is an admirable text for that - and it is also written in an enjoyably readable prose style.' - Cultural and Social History, 2009 "McWilliam argues that the Claimant's narrative can best be understood as a melodrama, a dramatic form then still in the mainstream of popular culture...In doing so, he has not only told us that story in its full delirious glory for the first time, but he has showed us how much "sense" it did make to contemporaries, and in doing so has made a genuinely important contribution to our understanding of popular consciousness-truly, a rescue of popular experience from the condescension of posterity." - Peter Mandler, H-Net Reviews, October 2007 -- Peter Mandler * H' Net Review * "Rohan McWilliam's account goes further in unteasing the many strands of this baffling and delightfully ludicrous affair" -- Sarah Wise * Literary Review * Mentioned in Publishing News, October 2007 * Publishing News * "Despite the esteemed former Tablet editor Douglas Woodruff's fine book on the subject, published 50 years ago, this thoroughly researched biography ought to be the standard work on the matter for our times." Tablet, July 2007 * Tablet, The *