The Caliph and the Imam

Reviews / Votes

Ambitious...undoubtedly an admirable study...an accessible introduction to the historical context that underpins the modern Middle East * Tariq Mir, BBC History Magazine * a remarkable, ambitious and successful survey of Sunni-Shii relations that will be the definitive single-volume study of the subject for years to come. * Eamonn Gearon, Times Literary Supplement * clearly written, nuanced and meticulously documented * Malise Ruthven, Literary Review * a truly ambitious book in its historical and geographic scope...This book should be read by any expert who deals in the Middle East * Francis Ghiles, Esglobal * A useful correction to religious pigeonholes about Muslims, and to the easy-going prejudice that sectarian differences can never make things right with the Islamic world. * Michiel Leezenberg, NRC Handelsblad * Matthiesen's masterful survey of Sunni-Shiite relations in history is firmly grounded in the primary sources and ranges more widely geographically than is common in other works on the subject, including South Asia. The author avoids the glib truisms that have come to dominate discussion of this subject, while giving us thought-provoking, contextual insights into one of the key flash points within Islamic civilization. * Juan Cole, Richard P. Mitchell Collegiate Professor of History and Director, Program in Arab and Muslim American Studies, University of Michigan * Ambitious in its historical as well as geographical scope, this is the first truly global account of the intimate and sometimes also violent relationship of Sunni and Shia in the making and remaking of Islam. * Faisal Devji, Professor of Indian History, University of Oxford * The Caliph and the Imam is an ambitious book .... The book will be of interest to those readers seeking a comprehensive in-depth historical survey of sectarian relations in Islam and Middle Eastern and South Asian history. * Christopher Anzalone, The Muslim World Book Review * The Caliph and the Imam is an ambitious book...The book will be of interest to those readers seeking a comprehensive in-depth historical survey of sectarian relations in Islam and Middle Eastern and South Asian history. * The Muslim World Book Review * The Caliph and the Imam is a hefty read, but all too rewarding for those who wish to understand how we got here. * Survival * Toby Matthiesen is quickly establishing himself as one of the more interesting historians of the Middle East. He has widened his lens in The Caliph and the Imam, grappling with the sectarian divisions that have plagued the region starting when the Prophet Muhammad was alive and continuing through to the Arab Spring. His thesis, that the sectarian divide was present from the beginning but became much more toxic after European colonial powers carved up the Middle East, is as provocative as it is insightful. * Ray Takeyh, Survival: Global Politics and Strategy * The book's thoroughly researched content, compelling documents and evidence, anddelightful blend of detailed analysis with a broader perspective make it accessible to scholars, students, and general audiences alike. It not only raises important questions and inspires new avenues of study but is also highly relevant to those interested in the history of religion, theological developments, Islamic studies, Political Islam, identity politics, and modernization in the MENA region and Indian Subcontinent. Additionally, it helps curious readers explore the roots of many contemporary misunderstandings between the West and Muslims and the reactionaryand radically polarized currents in the MENA region. * Sayed Hassan Akhlaq, Religion * This book is highly recommended for its comprehensive historical analysis, offering a global historical and post-colonial perspective on the intricate relationship between Sunnism and Shiism. * Muhammad Adiz Wasisto, Religious Studies Review * The book remains a milestone for students of Shia-Sunnirelations, as it provides an extensive guide to the subject and offers plenty of references and suggestions for readers to delve deeper into issues that are only briefly touched upon. * Giulia Daga, The International Spectator *