The Force of Tradition
Response and Resistance in Literature, Religion, and Cultural Studies
Published on 16. August 2005
Book
Hardback
280 pages
978-0-7425-4161-0 (ISBN)
Description
How do we stand in relation to everything that comes down to us from the past? Is the very idea of tradition still useful in the wake of historical ruptures, such as the Holocaust, changes in the canon, and the end of colonialism? The concept of tradition has gained renewed importance in recent cultural studies. Suspicion of tradition as culturally narrow and oppressive is a persistent theme of modernity and has increased lately with the resurgence of religious traditionalism around the globe. At the same time, various groups demanding recognition for their distinctive cultural identity have reclaimed their traditions. Philosophers from Josiah Royce and Hans-Georg Gadamer to Alasdair MacIntyre have explored the relations between tradition and themes such as freedom, community, self-assertion, originality, and the shared values and interpretations that constitute everyday life. The essays in this volume offer varying, even disparate analyses of religious, literary, and cultural traditions and both responses and resistance to them in a variety of philosophers, novelists, and theologians. They examine works by Gadamer, Royce, MacIntyre, Plato, Jacques Derrida, Charlotte Bronte, S'ren Kierkegaard, Ludwig Wittgenstein, Edith Wharton, Chinua Achebe, John Fowles, Heinrich Bsll, Samuel Taylor Coleridge, Cotton Mather, Thomas Kuhn, Mikhail Bakhtin, Donald Davidson, Antebellum African-American women preachers, and Christian and Jewish thinkers in the wake of the Holocaust.
Reviews / Votes
In this delightfully angular collection, Donald Marshall conducts a conversation with insightful interlocutors in such creatively dialectical fashion as to press into the tough hermeneutical issues and yet simultaneously offer fresh readings of certain accomodatingly resilient texts. This is a conversation deeply indebted to tradition, yet which challenges and extends our appreciation of how tradition works when it works, as also how it ossifies, atrophies or collapses in upon itself when it fails the test of apparent contradiction. Marshall's own excursus upon Plato's introduction to such matters in the Symposium is a brilliant harbinger of very good critical reflection to come in the subsequent essays. -- David Lyle Jeffrey, Provost and Distinguished Professor of Literature and Humanities, Baylor University Without sparing the rod of intellectual rigor, this is a sympathetic and broad-ranging anthology of essays renewing and complicating the concept of tradition from Plato to Gadamer and beyond. The editor adds an exemplary introduction. -- Geoffrey Hartman, Sterling Professor Emeritus of English and Comparative Literature, Yale UniversityMore details
Language
English
Place of publication
United States
Publishing group
Bloomsbury Publishing Plc
Product notice
Laminated cover
Dimensions
Height: 235 mm
Width: 157 mm
Thickness: 21 mm
Weight
608 gr
ISBN-13
978-0-7425-4161-0 (9780742541610)
Copyright in bibliographic data and cover images is held by Nielsen Book Services Limited or by the publishers or by their respective licensors: all rights reserved.
Schweitzer Classification
Persons
Donald G. Marshall is Fletcher Jones Chair of Great Books at Pepperdine University. With Joel Weinsheimer, he revised the translation of Hans-Georg Gadamer's Truth and Method (1989). He compiled Contemporary Critical Theory: A Selective Bibliography (1993) and has published articles on the theory and history of criticism and rhetoric
Content
Chapter 1 Introduction: The Force of Tradition
Chapter 2 Tradition and the Terror of History: Christianity, the Holocaust, and the Jewish Theological Dilemma
Chapter 3 Charity Militant: Gadamer, Davidson, and Post-Critical Hermeneutics
Chapter 4 "In the Chorus of Others": M. M. Bakhtin's Sense of Tradition
Chapter 5 The Role of the Kuhnian Paradigm in Tradition and Originality
Chapter 6 Walking vs. Flying: Kierkegaard on Tradition and the Moral Import of Literature
Chapter 7 My Own Private New England: Tradition, the Self, and the State in Cotton Mather's Wonders of the Invisible World
Chapter 8 Holy Fire: Biblical Radicalism in the Narratives of Jarena Lee and Zilpha Elaw
Chapter 9 ESTESE and Doblado: Coleridge, Blanco White, and the Church of Rome
Chapter 10 Jane Eyre and the Tradition of Self-Assertion; or Bronte's Socialization of Schiller's "Play Aesthetic"
Chapter 11 Tradition and Liberation: A Critique of German Cultural Modernity in Heinrich Boell and Hans-Georg Gadamer
Chapter 12 Community, Text, and Tradition in The French Lieutenant's Woman
Chapter 13 Storytellers and Interpreters in Achebe
Chapter 14 Contributors
Chapter 2 Tradition and the Terror of History: Christianity, the Holocaust, and the Jewish Theological Dilemma
Chapter 3 Charity Militant: Gadamer, Davidson, and Post-Critical Hermeneutics
Chapter 4 "In the Chorus of Others": M. M. Bakhtin's Sense of Tradition
Chapter 5 The Role of the Kuhnian Paradigm in Tradition and Originality
Chapter 6 Walking vs. Flying: Kierkegaard on Tradition and the Moral Import of Literature
Chapter 7 My Own Private New England: Tradition, the Self, and the State in Cotton Mather's Wonders of the Invisible World
Chapter 8 Holy Fire: Biblical Radicalism in the Narratives of Jarena Lee and Zilpha Elaw
Chapter 9 ESTESE and Doblado: Coleridge, Blanco White, and the Church of Rome
Chapter 10 Jane Eyre and the Tradition of Self-Assertion; or Bronte's Socialization of Schiller's "Play Aesthetic"
Chapter 11 Tradition and Liberation: A Critique of German Cultural Modernity in Heinrich Boell and Hans-Georg Gadamer
Chapter 12 Community, Text, and Tradition in The French Lieutenant's Woman
Chapter 13 Storytellers and Interpreters in Achebe
Chapter 14 Contributors