This Dark Night

Reviews / Votes

Refreshing... [Lutz] is excellent on the intimacy of Emily's writing about grief... this biography is a wonderful book. * Guardian * It says much for Lutz's skills as a writer that she succeeds in creating such a seamless and compelling narrative out of her materials. Her insight and sensitivity as a critic, as well her deep knowledge of the sources, allow her to open up the inner life of her famously reclusive subject. The result is a convincing portrait and an impressive achievement. -- Lucasta Miller * The Spectator * Discerning * Independent (in their May 2026 'Books of the Month' list) * A dazzling, rigorously researched biography of Emily Bronte. Lutz paints a vivid portrait of a singular, peculiar writer. Readers will be rapt. * Publishers Weekly * Deborah Lutz reveals Emily Bronte to us anew in this fresh, compelling, and perfectly paced jewel of a biography. Lutz dispenses with the Bronte myth and gives us a far more moving and accurate portrait of a bold, innovative, emotionally attuned writer deeply rooted in her imagination, family, landscape, and community. This Dark Night is a triumph. * Heather Clark, Pulitzer Prize-finalist author of Red Comet: The Short Life and Blazing Art of Sylvia Plath * A lively, comprehensive, and thoroughly researched biography... Lutz paints a vivid portrait of the surroundings, people and politics... This Dark Night, underpinned by wide-ranging sources and expert analysis, is a discerning insight into the woman behind a tale which has captivated generations. * The Press Association * Lutz has a nice, if slightly lush turn of phrase...and is particularly good on weather, landscape and conjuring up sensory experiences. * The Times * In This Dark Night, Lutz paints Emily Bronte's life with exquisite detail. The completeness of this biography means we are given as much a picture of the material lives of Emily as we are her intellectual life, so one can feel it all: her chilblains, her handwriting cramped onto folded manuscripts, her dog, her sisters and her beloved moors. Everything comes alive just as it might in a Bronte novel. I find myself returning to the world of the Parsonage, to Emily's Gothic playground, again and again through this book. * Sarvat Hasin, author of Strange Girls * Atmospheric and empathetic... A thoughtful, imaginative portrait that brings fresh interpretation to familiar ground. * Kirkus Reviews * Splendid...Lutz's exhilarating prose animates This Dark Night, lending fresh insights into the life and writing of one of literature's most enduring authors. * BookPage * I loved this illuminating, comprehensive biography. -- Caroline Sanderson * The Bookseller * Deborah Lutz's extraordinary This Dark Night gives us a wilder and more wonder-filled Emily Bronte than any previous account of the famed sisterhood. Lutz knows her subject the way Bronte knew the Yorkshire moors, and her biography 'blazes forth,' as an early reviewer wrote of Wuthering Heights, with a rare brilliance derived from passionate and abiding engagement. * Megan Marshall, Pulitzer Prize-winning author of Margaret Fuller: A New American Life * Deborah Lutz reimagines what literary biography can do, interlacing details of life and text with a luminous prose that achieves a kind of resurrection. Haunting and gorgeous, like a windy moonlit moor. * Natalie Dykstra, author of Chasing Beauty: The Life of Isabella Stewart Gardner * This Dark Night is an extraordinary act of biographical reanimation - not only of the strange, enigmatic Emily Bronte, who has never been more vividly rendered, but also of Bronte's physical world, the smells and textures and sounds of her beloved West Yorkshire moors. This gorgeous book hums with vitality. * Lance Richardson, author of True Nature: The Pilgrimage of Peter Matthiessen *