Beyond Jewish Identity
Rethinking Concepts and Imagining Alternatives
Published on 17. September 2019
Book
Hardback
290 pages
978-1-64469-116-8 (ISBN)
Description
There is something deeply problematic about
the ways that Jews, particularly in America, talk about "Jewish identity" as a
desired outcome of Jewish education. For many, the idea that the purpose of
Jewish education is to strengthen Jewish identity is so obvious that it hardly
seems worth disputing-and the only important question is which kinds of Jewish
education do that work more effectively or more efficiently. But what does it
mean to "strengthen Jewish identity"? Why do Jewish educators, policy-makers
and philanthropists talk that way? What do they assume, about Jewish education
or about Jewish identity, when they use formulations like "strengthen Jewish
identity"? And what are the costs of doing so?
This volume, the first collection to
examine critically the relationship between Jewish education and Jewish
identity, makes two important interventions. First, it offers a critical
assessment of the relationship between education and identity, arguing that the
reification of identity has hampered much educational creativity in the pursuit
of this goal, and that the nearly ubiquitous employment of the term obscures
significant questions about what Jewish education is and ought to be. Second,
this volume offers thoughtful responses that are not merely synonymous
replacements for "identity," suggesting new possibilities for how to think
about the purposes and desired outcomes of Jewish education, potentially contributing
to any number of new conversations about the relationship between Jewish education
and Jewish life.
the ways that Jews, particularly in America, talk about "Jewish identity" as a
desired outcome of Jewish education. For many, the idea that the purpose of
Jewish education is to strengthen Jewish identity is so obvious that it hardly
seems worth disputing-and the only important question is which kinds of Jewish
education do that work more effectively or more efficiently. But what does it
mean to "strengthen Jewish identity"? Why do Jewish educators, policy-makers
and philanthropists talk that way? What do they assume, about Jewish education
or about Jewish identity, when they use formulations like "strengthen Jewish
identity"? And what are the costs of doing so?
This volume, the first collection to
examine critically the relationship between Jewish education and Jewish
identity, makes two important interventions. First, it offers a critical
assessment of the relationship between education and identity, arguing that the
reification of identity has hampered much educational creativity in the pursuit
of this goal, and that the nearly ubiquitous employment of the term obscures
significant questions about what Jewish education is and ought to be. Second,
this volume offers thoughtful responses that are not merely synonymous
replacements for "identity," suggesting new possibilities for how to think
about the purposes and desired outcomes of Jewish education, potentially contributing
to any number of new conversations about the relationship between Jewish education
and Jewish life.
Reviews / Votes
"Levisohn and Kelman's instructive collection of essays on Jewish identity and education... is situated in a solid understanding of the problems with the concept of identity and the difficulties this raises for Jewish educators who have made the construction or 'strengthening' of Jewish identity the goal of their efforts."- Stephen Frosh, University of London, Journal of Modern Jewish Studies 21:4
"It's a good thing for the Jewish educational domain to question the ways that funders and other stakeholders understand the work of educators, schools, and other educational institutions. The book succeeds in pushing back against the heavy hand of funders' expectations about how individual educational enterprises are supposed to yield subsequent Jewish identities. ... The editors of this volume are to be commended for gathering together this stimulating collection of essays to focus our attention on the relationship between Jewish identity and Jewish education. I hope this book leads to many more focused studies that will illuminate and extend the important questions it provokes."
- Bethamie Horowitz, New York University, Journal of Jewish Education
"If you have any connection to the world of Jewish education, you've heard the phrase 'Jewish Identity' thrown about. However, it is rarely and inconsistently defined. Is it a tool towards a specific outcome or a goal unto itself? What assumptions are Jewish educators making and what are their blind spots? This excellent collection of studies tackles these questions and presents several ways of reframing priorities for Jewish education. Some overlap in the content occurs in some chapters, but not overly so. Highly recommended."
- Daniel Scheide, Florida Atlantic University, AJL Reviews
"'Jewish identity' is such a complex idea-neither simply a religious, nor cultural, nor ethnic 'identity,' but all of those things combined (and more). This important volume rejects narrow definitions and resists the way that 'identity' has been oversimplified and flattened in Jewish communal contexts. Along the way, it offers new paths for other communities struggling with concepts of identity to follow as well."
- Felicia Herman, Executive Director, Natan Fund
"At once both a useful exploration of how the term 'Jewish identity' came to dominate the discourse of American Jewish elites and a probing analysis of the term's appropriation to define the goals of Jewish education, Beyond Jewish Identity offers a no-holds-barred critique of the politics surrounding the term. Collectively, the accomplished scholars assembled in this volume make the case for shifting the focus from how Jews feel to how they act as Jews."
- Jack Wertheimer, Professor of American Jewish History, Jewish Theological Seminary
"What are we talking about when we talk about Jewish identity? The Jewish community sorely needs a dose of clarity and discernment about this vital question. This volume not only unmasks the many problems with how we use that phrase, but also reveals the fruitful concepts buried within it, paving our way forward to a new understanding of exactly what elements of flourishing Jewish life our community's organizations and leaders can build and sustain."
- Andres Spokoiny, President & CEO, Jewish Funders Network
"Beyond Jewish Identity interrogates the long-standing premise that the goal of Jewish education is to strengthen a monolithic 'Jewish identity,' challenging us to create more specific and more aspirational goals and pushing us to broaden our understanding of 'Jewish identity' beyond the traditional measures of 'greater religious observance' or 'Jewish affiliation.' Most Jews carry a multiplicity of identities. This book articulates a set of frameworks for pursuing this important, timely conversation."
- Angela Buchdal, Senior Rabbi, Central Synagogue
More details
Language
English
Place of publication
Brighton
United States
Target group
College/higher education
Product notice
Laminated cover
Illustrations
Illustrations
Dimensions
Height: 240 mm
Width: 161 mm
Thickness: 20 mm
Weight
602 gr
ISBN-13
978-1-64469-116-8 (9781644691168)
Copyright in bibliographic data and cover images is held by Nielsen Book Services Limited or by the publishers or by their respective licensors: all rights reserved.
Schweitzer Classification
Persons
Jon A. Levisohn is the Jack, Joseph and Morton Mandel Associate Professor
of Jewish Educational Thought at Brandeis University, where he serves as the
director of the Jack, Joseph and Morton Mandel Center for Studies in Jewish
Education.
Ari Y. Kelman is Jim Joseph Associate
Professor of Education and Jewish Studies at Stanford University, where he
serves as director of the Concentration in Education and Jewish Studies.
of Jewish Educational Thought at Brandeis University, where he serves as the
director of the Jack, Joseph and Morton Mandel Center for Studies in Jewish
Education.
Ari Y. Kelman is Jim Joseph Associate
Professor of Education and Jewish Studies at Stanford University, where he
serves as director of the Concentration in Education and Jewish Studies.
Content
Contents
1. Introduction
Jon A. Levisohn and Ari Y. Kelman
2. Taking Jewish Identity Metaphors Literally
Eli Gottlieb
3. You are Jewish if You Want to Be: The Limits of Identity in a World of Multiple Practices
Samira K. Mehta
4. On the Origins and Persistence of the Jewish Identity Industry in Jewish Education
Jonathan Krasner
5. Identity and Crisis: The Origins of Identity as an Educational Outcome
Ari Y. Kelman
6. Regarding the "Real" Jew: Authenticity Anxieties Around Poland's "Generation Unexpected"
Katka Reszke
7. Re-Thinking American Jewish Zionist Identity: A Case for Post-Zionism in the Diaspora (Based on the Writings of R. Menachem Froman)
Shaul Magid
8. Jewish Educators Don't Make Jews: A Sociological Reality Check About Jewish Identity Work
Tali Zelkowicz
9. Beyond Language Proficiency: Fostering Metalinguistic Communities in Jewish Educational Settings
Sarah Bunin Benor and Netta Avineri
10. Where is the Next Soviet Jewry Movement? How Identity Education Forgot the Lessons that Jewish Activism Taught
Shaul Kelner
11. Jewish Education as Initiation into the Practices of Jewishness
Jon A. Levisohn
12. Jewish Sensibilities: Toward a New Language for Jewish Educational Goal-Setting
Lee Moore and Jonathan Woocher, z''l
1. Introduction
Jon A. Levisohn and Ari Y. Kelman
2. Taking Jewish Identity Metaphors Literally
Eli Gottlieb
3. You are Jewish if You Want to Be: The Limits of Identity in a World of Multiple Practices
Samira K. Mehta
4. On the Origins and Persistence of the Jewish Identity Industry in Jewish Education
Jonathan Krasner
5. Identity and Crisis: The Origins of Identity as an Educational Outcome
Ari Y. Kelman
6. Regarding the "Real" Jew: Authenticity Anxieties Around Poland's "Generation Unexpected"
Katka Reszke
7. Re-Thinking American Jewish Zionist Identity: A Case for Post-Zionism in the Diaspora (Based on the Writings of R. Menachem Froman)
Shaul Magid
8. Jewish Educators Don't Make Jews: A Sociological Reality Check About Jewish Identity Work
Tali Zelkowicz
9. Beyond Language Proficiency: Fostering Metalinguistic Communities in Jewish Educational Settings
Sarah Bunin Benor and Netta Avineri
10. Where is the Next Soviet Jewry Movement? How Identity Education Forgot the Lessons that Jewish Activism Taught
Shaul Kelner
11. Jewish Education as Initiation into the Practices of Jewishness
Jon A. Levisohn
12. Jewish Sensibilities: Toward a New Language for Jewish Educational Goal-Setting
Lee Moore and Jonathan Woocher, z''l