Return

Reviews / Votes

A hauntingly written, remorselessly honest, and surely long lasting account of Palestinian loss and struggle. -- Donald MacIntyre * Independent * This moving memoir takes us to the heart of a conflict that must be resolved if we are to have a peaceful and viable world; Karmi gives us a valuable insight into the impasse in which the Palestinian people find themselves and enables us to experience the anomaly of their situation. -- Karen Armstrong, author of <i>Fields of Blood</i> Eloquent and moving. -- David Shulman * New York Review of Books * Personal, warm and accessible, Return describes a life trajectory that captures the story of modern Palestine in a most unique and sensitive way. Beautifully written, it brings to the fore the human being behind the colonized, occupied and fragmented realities of present-day Israel and Palestine. It is an individual journey into the heart of the occupation's darkness, where people, and not abstract ideas, are struggling with the impossibility of leading a normal life, or any life at all. -- Ilan Pappe, author of <i>The Idea of Israel</i> Ghada Karmi is versatile, cosmopolitan and highly intelligent, and comes across as both self-absorbed and deeply committed to the struggle for Palestinian rights. In Search of Fatima was a beautifully written and moving narrative of her displacement from Jerusalem in 1948 set against the backdrop of the major political events that shaped the course of modern Palestinian history. Return is both a sequel and a stand-alone memoir. On display is the same fluent writing style, the psychological insight and the outstanding skill for mixing the personal with the political. -- Avi Shlaim * Guardian * A haunting account of a Palestinian's sense of loss. * Belfast Telegraph * Karmi's strength is to focus on her personal story. Some of the best chapters in her book relate to her visit to Amman to see her centenarian father . She describes astutely how the Palestinians in Jordan have distanced themselves psychically from their brethren under Israeli occupation, as if their depredations had made Jordan's Palestinians decide 'they wanted no part of that misery' . The sheer bloody-mindedness of Israeli bureaucracy, honed over the decades into a machine to humiliate and intimidate, runs like a thread through the book. * New Statesman * Not just life writing but writing that is alive. With perfectly attuned fidelity to the experiences it narrates, it offers a deeply engaged and engaging meditation on what it means to stay together as a people. Revolving this question in ways both existentially Palestinian and universally human, it is a literary memoir to be placed alongside those of Mourid Barghouti and Mahmoud Darwish. -- Caroline Rooney, Professor of African and Middle Eastern Studies, University of Kent [In Ghada Karmi's Return], the reality of Palestinian life begins to come into focus. It is the reality of exile. -- Yasmine El Rashidi * Bookforum *