The Trolley Problem Mysteries
Published on 20. June 2019
Book
Paperback/Softback
264 pages
978-0-19-094911-2 (ISBN)
Description
Suppose you can stop a trolley from killing five people, but only by turning it onto a side track where it will kill one. May you turn the trolley? What if the only way to rescue the five is to topple a bystander in front of the trolley so that his body stops it but he dies? May you use a device to stop the trolley that will kill a bystander as a side effect? The "trolley problem" challenges us to explain and justify our different intuitive judgments about these and related cases. Frances Kamm's 2013 Tanner Lectures present some of her views on this notorious moral conundrum. After providing a brief history of changing views of what the problem is about and attempts to solve it, she focuses on two prominent issues: Does who turns the trolley and how the harm is shifted affect the moral permissibility of acting? The answers to these questions lead to general proposals about when we may and may not harm some to help others. Three distinguished philosophers - Judith Jarvis Thomson (one of the originators of the trolley problem), Thomas Hurka, and Shelly Kagan - then comment on Kamm's proposals. She responds to each comment at length, providing an exceptionally rich elaboration and defense of her views. This book is invaluable not only to philosophers concerned about the trolley problem, but to anyone worried about how we ought to act when we can lessen harm to some by harming others and how we can reach a decision about the question.
Reviews / Votes
subtle, brilliant ... Kamm's forte lies [in] the illuminating new perspectives and puzzles she opens up. * Jane O'Grady, Times Higher Education * In response to her commentators Kamm tries to answer these objections and many other objections. And these remarkable exchanges between some leading contributors make this book really invaluable. I suggest reading this book to every graduate student or moral philosopher who wishes to know lots of hypothetical cases in which the trolley problem happens. * Ebrahim Azadegan, Metapsychology Online Reviews * ... the book is best seen as an overview of the important contributions that Kamm and her interlocutors have made to the literature. It is also a rich source of cases for testing new hypotheses -- cases ranging from ingenious classics like Transplant, Driver, and Bystander, to some newer developments like Driver Topple and Thomsonas Loop Case, to some particularly perplexing cases involving tractors and bombs ... the trolley problem is still as real, pressing, and fascinating as ever, and it is helpful to have as oneas guide through the problem a philosopher who does not shy away from complexities. * Molly Gardiner, Ethics * Professor Frances Myrna Kamm, a moral philosopher who for decades has been a leading analyst of this thought experiment, has now published her richly stimulating Tanner Lectures. Joining her lectures as chapters in the book are a trio of rigorous and unrelenting responses from a panel of philosophersProfessors Judith Jarvis Thomson, Thomas Hurka, and Shelly Kaganas well as an introduction by legal scholar Professor Eric RakowskiThe beating heart of this book is a fresh, often raw, analytical quarrel between Kamm and ThomsonThe books timing is impeccabledue in part to its uncanny resemblance to emergent questions about how to program autonomous vehiclessuch as military drones or driverless carsto act ethically. * Harvard Law Review *More details
Series
Language
English
Place of publication
New York
United States
Illustrations
18
Dimensions
Height: 203 mm
Width: 133 mm
Thickness: 16 mm
Weight
346 gr
ISBN-13
978-0-19-094911-2 (9780190949112)
Copyright in bibliographic data and cover images is held by Nielsen Book Services Limited or by the publishers or by their respective licensors: all rights reserved.
Schweitzer Classification
Other editions
Additional editions
F. M. Kamm | Eric Rakowski
The Trolley Problem Mysteries
E-Book
11/2015
1st Edition
OUP eBook
€9.99
Available for download
Persons
F. M. Kamm is Littauer Professor of Philosophy and Public Policy in the Kennedy School of Government at Harvard University and a Professor of Philosophy, Faculty of Arts and Sciences within the Philosophy Department at Harvard University. Kamm is also author of Intricate Ethics (OUP 2010) and Bioethical Prescriptions (OUP 2013), and others.
Eric Rakowski is Edward C. Halbach Jr. Professor of Law at University of California Berkeley.
Eric Rakowski is Edward C. Halbach Jr. Professor of Law at University of California Berkeley.
Author
Littauer Professor of Philosophy and Public Policy in the Kennedy School of Government at Harvard University and Professor of Philosophy, Faculty of Arts and Sciences within the Philosophy Department at Harvard University.Littauer Professor of Philosophy and Public Policy in the Kennedy School of Government at Harvard University and Professor of Philosophy, Faculty of Arts and Sciences within the Philosophy Department at Harvard University.
Editor
Edward C. Halbach Jr. Professor of LawEdward C. Halbach Jr. Professor of Law, UC Berkeley
Content
List of Contributors
Introduction
Eric Rakowski
The Trolley Problem Mysteries
F.M. Kamm
Lecture I: Who Turned the Trolley?
Lecture II: How Was the Trolley Turned?
Diagrams
Comments
Kamm on the Trolley Problems
Judith Jarvis Thomson
Trolleys and Permissible Harm
Thomas Hurka
Solving the Trolley Problem
Shelly Kagan
F.M Kamm
Trolley Problem Mysteries on Trial: Defending the Trolley Problem, A Type of Solution to It, and a Method of Ethics
Index of Names
Introduction
Eric Rakowski
The Trolley Problem Mysteries
F.M. Kamm
Lecture I: Who Turned the Trolley?
Lecture II: How Was the Trolley Turned?
Diagrams
Comments
Kamm on the Trolley Problems
Judith Jarvis Thomson
Trolleys and Permissible Harm
Thomas Hurka
Solving the Trolley Problem
Shelly Kagan
F.M Kamm
Trolley Problem Mysteries on Trial: Defending the Trolley Problem, A Type of Solution to It, and a Method of Ethics
Index of Names