Haunting Legacy
Vietnam and the American Presidency from Ford to Obama
Published on 26. May 2011
Book
Hardback
300 pages
978-0-8157-2131-4 (ISBN)
Description
The United States had never lost a war -that is, until 1975, when it was forced to flee Saigon in humiliation after losing to what Lyndon Johnson called a "raggedy-ass little fourth-rate country." The legacy of this first defeat has haunted every president since, especially on the decision of whether to put "boots on the ground" and commit troops to war.
In Haunting Legacy, the father-daughter journalist team of Marvin Kalb and Deborah Kalb presents a compelling, accessible, and hugely important history of presidential decisionmaking on one crucial issue: in light of the Vietnam debacle, under what circumstances should the United States go to war?
The sobering lesson of Vietnam is that the United States is not invincible -it can lose a war -and thus it must be more discriminating about the use of American power. Every president has faced the ghosts of Vietnam in his own way, though each has been wary of being sucked into another unpopular war. Ford (during the Mayaguez crisis) and both Bushes (Persian Gulf, Iraq, Afghanistan) deployed massive force, as if to say, "Vietnam, be damned." On the other hand, Carter, Clinton, and Reagan (to the surprise of many) acted with extreme caution, mindful of the Vietnam experience. Obama has also wrestled with the Vietnam legacy, using doses of American firepower in Libya while still engaged in Iraq and Afghanistan.
The authors spent five years interviewing hundreds of officials from every post war administration and conducting extensive research in presidential libraries and archives, and they've produced insight and information never before published. Equal parts taut history, revealing biography, and cautionary tale, Haunting Legacy is must reading for anyone trying to understand the power of the past to influence war-and-peace decisions of the present, and of the future.
In Haunting Legacy, the father-daughter journalist team of Marvin Kalb and Deborah Kalb presents a compelling, accessible, and hugely important history of presidential decisionmaking on one crucial issue: in light of the Vietnam debacle, under what circumstances should the United States go to war?
The sobering lesson of Vietnam is that the United States is not invincible -it can lose a war -and thus it must be more discriminating about the use of American power. Every president has faced the ghosts of Vietnam in his own way, though each has been wary of being sucked into another unpopular war. Ford (during the Mayaguez crisis) and both Bushes (Persian Gulf, Iraq, Afghanistan) deployed massive force, as if to say, "Vietnam, be damned." On the other hand, Carter, Clinton, and Reagan (to the surprise of many) acted with extreme caution, mindful of the Vietnam experience. Obama has also wrestled with the Vietnam legacy, using doses of American firepower in Libya while still engaged in Iraq and Afghanistan.
The authors spent five years interviewing hundreds of officials from every post war administration and conducting extensive research in presidential libraries and archives, and they've produced insight and information never before published. Equal parts taut history, revealing biography, and cautionary tale, Haunting Legacy is must reading for anyone trying to understand the power of the past to influence war-and-peace decisions of the present, and of the future.
Reviews / Votes
"What a terrific book! Scrupulously researched and beautifully told, Haunting Legacyproves that try as they might, our past seven presidents have -one after the next -
failed to exorcize the ghost of Vietnam. From Ford to Obama...each one has seen the
Vietnam War intrude on his campaigns (think draft dodging and swift boating) and
his decisionmaking (think military action). It's a fresh look at late 20th/early 21stcentury
American history." -Lesley Stahl, correspondent for 60 Minutes
|"The ghost of the Vietnam War has influenced and haunted two generations of
American policymakers. Now, a brilliant two-generation team looks at that legacy
in an insightful and fascinating way. This is great narrative history and biography
combined to create informative case studies." -Walter Isaacson
, president and CEO of the Aspen Institute
|"By God, we've kicked the Vietnam syndrome,' crowed President George H. W.
Bush when he repelled Iraq's invasion of Kuwait in 1991. He was wrong. The Vietnam
debacle continues to haunt America's political leaders, military men, and population.
Marvin Kalb and Deborah Kalb's account of this phenomenon is studiously researched,
vividly narrated, and, above all, highly readable. It will stand as a major contribution
to the subject." -Stanley Karnow, author of Vietnam: A
History, winner of the Pulitzer Prize
|"More than three decades after its end, the Vietnam War continues to influence American attitudes toward sending troops abroad. In readable prose, the Kalbs's book skillfully and perceptively analyzes this haunting legacy from the administration of Gerald Ford to that of Barack Obama." -George C. Herring, author, America's Longest War: The United States and Vietnam, 1950-1975
|"Vietnam continues to be an albatross, circling the White House. In a compelling
and totally accessible book, the Kalbs (father and daughter) show how profoundly
America's defeat in Vietnam has affected one U.S. administration after another, over
the course of the past thirty-six years. If you wonder whether Vietnam still matters,
it does. Read this book and discover why and how." -Ted Koppel, anchor of ABC's Nightline for twenty-five years
|" Haunting Legacy is a gripping, fascinating account of how the Vietnam War has lived
on in the psyches of our national leaders and put its stamp on our foreign policy ever
since. This powerful and insightful book shows us how that long and painful war has
never really ended in Washington." -Elizabeth Drew, political journalist
|"In this masterful work of historical reflection combined with good old-fashioned
reporting and research, the Kalbs remind us how the shadow of losing a war
influenced a president's choices on subsequent interventions. The chapters on
Obama and Afghanistan poignantly remind us that perhaps the most dangerous
form of human error is forgetting what one is trying to achieve. Haunting Legacy
should be required reading for all occupants of the White House and every
presidential aspirant." -Larry Berman, author of Lyndon Johnson's War: The Road to Stalemate in
Vietnam and No Peace, No Honor: Nixon, Kissinger and Betrayal in Vietnam
More details
Language
English
Place of publication
United States
Publishing group
Bloomsbury Publishing Plc
ISBN-13
978-0-8157-2131-4 (9780815721314)
Copyright in bibliographic data and cover images is held by Nielsen Book Services Limited or by the publishers or by their respective licensors: all rights reserved.
Schweitzer Classification
Other editions
Additional editions
E-Book
06/2011
1st Edition
Brookings Institution
€25.49
Available for download
Persons
Marvin Kalb is the Edward R. Murrow Professor of Practice (Emeritus) at Harvard's Kennedy School of Government and founding director of the Shorenstein Center on the Press, Politics and Public Policy, Massachusetts. His distinguished journalism career covers thirty years of award-winning reporting and commentary for CBS and NBC News, including stints as bureau chief in Moscow and host of Meet the Press . His eleven previous books include The Nixon Memo (University of Chicago) and Kissinger (Little Brown). He hosts the Kalb Report at the National Press Club. Deborah Kalb , a freelance writer and editor, worked as a journalist in Washington for two decades, including writing for Gannett News Service , Congressional Quarterly , U.S. News & World Report , and The Hill . Both authors live in the Washington, D.C. area.