Crafting Courts in New Democracies

Reviews / Votes

'Addressing critical questions about the most promising pathways to the establishment of honest and effective judicial systems in post-authoritarian Latin America, Ingram's rigorous, meticulously calibrated study shows that normative beliefs and commitments matter. In a discipline in which many assume ab initio that the only causal forces in politics are power and interest, Ingram scientifically demonstrates that the ideals and convictions of key actors concerning fairness, impartial justice, and the rule of law can have salubrious real-world effects that can potentially overcome retrograde political and material interests. This impressive contribution to the burgeoning 'court-building' literature counsels that, when it comes [to] establishing free, democratic institutions under the rule of law, we should care about the ideational commitments of their leaders, staffers, and supporters - about what they believe, how they think, and who they are.' Ken Kersch, Boston College, Massachusetts 'Matthew C. Ingram's new book is a much anticipated addition to the comparative public law literature. Ingram's project stands out not only for its theoretical innovations concerning judicial reform but also for its empirical contribution in covering two countries and their judicial systems about which we still have a lot to learn. Crafting Courts in New Democracies will prove invaluable for students of Latin American politics as much as for students of political institutions in general and judicial systems and judicial politics in particular.' Udi Sommer, Tel Aviv University 'Scholars of law and courts in the United States often take for granted the institutional integrity and independence of the judicial branch. Some focus on how to maintain judicial independence in the face of perceived or potential threats, and others fret about independent/unaccountable judges having too great a role in deciding fundamental policy issues, but the question of where strong and independent judicial institutions come from is mostly ignored or left to historians. For those who work on new (or renewed) democracies, by contrast, the question of how to construct (or reconstruct) stable, independent judiciaries is of fundamental concern, not just for scholars, but for citizens of those countries seeking to hold public and private actors accountable for legal violations. With Crafting Courts in New Democracies, Matthew C. Ingram offers an innovative and compelling contribution to this important line of research.' Lisa Hilbink, Law and Politics Book Review 'The theoretical scope of the book is ... broad, making contributions to the study of courts, comparative law, and the amplification of court strength while also addressing the literature that closed in on phenomena of uneven development across subnational units.' Jan Boesten, Latin American Research Review