Forgiveness and Retribution

Reviews / Votes

'Margaret Holmgren's book is a daring attempt to defend a new paradigm of forgiveness that would radically reorient our attitudes toward those who wrong us and our way of thinking about punishment and criminal law. No doubt the discussion it provokes will be intense.' George W. Harris, author of Reason's Grief: An Essay on Tragedy and Value 'Moral, political, and legal philosophers who prize theoretical unity and comprehensiveness will appreciate Margaret Holmgren's new book, which begins with a foundational virtue ethic and from it systematically derives conclusions about how individuals and institutions should respond to wrongdoers. Holmgren's work is probably the most thoughtful and thorough defense of an unconditional forgiveness approach to wrongdoers, one that critically responds to work by contemporary retributivists and that should give them pause. Of particular interest is the fact that Holmgren argues that principles such as respect for offenders and for victims, to which retributivists standardly appeal, are best interpreted in ways that support anti-retributivist conclusions, such as the restitutional approach to punishment for which Holmgren is rightly well-known.' Thaddeus Metz, Humanities Research Professor, University of Johannesburg 'Margaret Holmgren has written a very stimulating book on forgiveness ... An additional virtue of her book is a discussion of forgiveness in the context of criminal punishment - a discussion in which she makes creative suggestions concerning the social and legal institutions that a truly forgiving society would adopt. I recommend that all those interested in a serious discussion of forgiveness read this book and ponder its many insights.' Jeffrie G. Murphy, Arizona State University and author of Getting Even: Forgiveness and Its Limits '... forces us to think harder about predominantly retributivist and all-too-settled models of response to harm ... It is a book for exercising one's arguments, a service to philosophy.' Philosophy in Review