The Catch

Reviews / Votes

'The Catch represents a landmark contribution to pre-modern environmental history. Its multi-disciplinary approach to the ecosystems, habitats, consumers, and exploiters of medieval fisheries convincingly tracks historic changes in fisheries caused not only by human contact but also by climatic conditions that affected hydrology, biology, and ecology. Supported with numerous charts, maps, and data drawn from research on a wide variety of source material across Europe, Hoffman's study will be the standard work in the field for years to come.' Maryanne Kowaleski, Fordham University 'Richard Hoffman's book is a marvellous synthesis of his lifetime of research into fish, fishing, and fish consumption in the Middle Ages. He has seamlessly integrated historic records, archaeology, fish ecology and biology. The case studies that document the decline of certain species make it crucial reading for fishery biologists as well as historians and archaeologists.' Dale Serjeantson, University of Southampton 'This remarkable book demonstrates the powerful insights that can be gained from combining documentary and archaeological evidence on a subject which is central to a full understanding of the medieval past.' Christopher Dyer, Medieval Archaeology 'Through thorough research and engaging writing, Hoffman has written an important read for historians, environmentalists, and all who are fascinated by the intricate relationship between human societies and the natural world. The book not only enriches our understanding of medieval Europe but also provides important perspectives on contemporary environmental issues and our relationship to water systems in all its forms.' Wanda Marcussen, H-Soz-Kult '[A] magisterial analysis of a millennium of humanity's relationship with fish in the inland and coastal waters of Europe and the deeper seas that lie to our south and west. The product of over thirty years of continent-spanning archival research, contextualized through archaeological, palaeoenvironmental and fisheries science data, all interleaved with the personal experience of a passionate angler, this book presents to us a narrative of breathtaking scope. Hoffmann's judicious selection of historical and archaeological case studies and clear exposition of trophic pyramids and nutrient cycles, open deep insights into the complex interplay of anthropogenic, climatic and wider environmental factors that led from abundance to dearth in a natural resource long regarded as 'inexhaustible'.' Richard Oram, Agricultural History Review 'The work is an outstanding and fascinating work of environmental history that reveals changes in European fisheries caused by humans and natural phenomena, which have had an impact on hydrology, biology, and ecology ... Richard Hoffmann has published important historical works in the past. The Catch is, in any case, the undisputed pinnacle, a masterpiece, the synthesis of his lifelong research on fish. One can only wish it many readers from all disciplines, but certainly from history, archaeology, and biology. The book deserves it.' Christoph Sonnlechner, Mitteilungen des Instituts fuer OEsterreichische Geschichtsforschung '... an invaluable work ... The Catch should expand the traditional focus of medieval studies, while also articulating the importance of multidisciplinarity ... Environmental history is often a story of continuum. Within this book, it is a story of later medieval commercialized maritime fishing that developed out of early medieval artisanal practices. By the book's end, Hoffmann has achieved his goal of explaining environmental Europeanization across the continent, which he sees as a core step toward globalization. This critical element to our successful understanding of anthropogenic crisis cannot be stated too often.' Victoria L. McAlister, H-Environment