The Parthenon Marbles Dispute
Heritage, Law, Politics
Published on 21. September 2023
Book
Hardback
288 pages
978-1-5099-6718-6 (ISBN)
Description
Why are we still arguing over the Parthenon Marbles? This book offers a fresh take on the history of those famous pieces of ancient sculpture removed from the Acropolis in Athens by Lord Elgin's men in the early 19th century. It explains how they became the cause celebre of the larger debates around cultural heritage and restitution now taking place. The subject is one that is currently embroiling museums, governments, universities and the public at large.
Herman provides a balanced, thorough and critical account of the history of the Marbles, while considering the legalities of their initial removal and the ethics of their retention by the British Museum. It incorporates the views of curators, museum directors, lawyers, archaeologists, politicians and others in both London and Athens. It explains why this particular dispute has not been satisfactorily resolved, and suggests new ways of seeking resolution - for the Parthenon Marbles and for the many other cultural treasures held in museum collections outside their countries of origin.
The book sets out a way forward for this famously intractable dispute, one based on evidence of past practice, legal rules around the transfer of cultural objects and the role of museums in negotiating international exchanges.
Herman provides a balanced, thorough and critical account of the history of the Marbles, while considering the legalities of their initial removal and the ethics of their retention by the British Museum. It incorporates the views of curators, museum directors, lawyers, archaeologists, politicians and others in both London and Athens. It explains why this particular dispute has not been satisfactorily resolved, and suggests new ways of seeking resolution - for the Parthenon Marbles and for the many other cultural treasures held in museum collections outside their countries of origin.
The book sets out a way forward for this famously intractable dispute, one based on evidence of past practice, legal rules around the transfer of cultural objects and the role of museums in negotiating international exchanges.
Reviews / Votes
Essential reading for those interested in the dispute, and indeed in the wider debate around repatriation of cultural objects. -- James Morton * The Times * Given Herman's legal credentials, readers might not expect the sensitivity he brings to questions far removed from parsing the clauses of Ottoman decrees ... Plenty of clear-eyed research and sufficient goodwill. * Literary Review of Canada * [An] even-handed and refreshing approach to this immensely complex dispute ... An important contribution has been made to identify areas of compromise that might help resolve this long-running dispute. * Returning Heritage * Alexander Herman has written a lucid and engaging guide to the world's longest-standing cultural dispute. Like so many of us, he hopes for its resolution, and is scrupulously fair and even-handed in explaining how this might happen. * Barnaby Phillips, author of 'Loot: Britain and the Benin Bronzes' * Anyone with an interest in world history and cultural heritage will learn a lot from reading this careful study of the world's toughest argument over art and restitution. Its approach is both rigorous and empathetic, an impressive combination. * Bruce Clark, Economist writer on history, culture and ideas, Author of 'Athens: City of Wisdom' * It is a remarkable achievement to write with such balance and authority on so fraught a question, even more impressive when so many believe they have an answer; from now on no-one should venture an opinion without reading this gripping and important analysis. * Sir Alan Moses, former Lord Justice of Appeal and co-chair of the UK's Spoliation Advisory Panel * This is a great book, with very useful up-to-date insights into the subject's history. But it doesn't stop there. Substantial, thoughtful essays on law, museums, nations and conflict resolution are valuable not just to this dispute, but to other comparable cases as well. * Mike Pitts * I recommend it as a solid introduction to the story of the Marbles and the subject of cultural property. * National Museum of Ireland * Both authors offer to scholars, the public and decision-makers abundant and serious arguments in support of the cause of the Marbles' homecoming after a forced exile of more than two centuries. -- Giorgio Sacerdoti * Italian Yearbook of International Law *More details
Series
Language
English
Place of publication
Oxford
United Kingdom
Publishing group
Bloomsbury Publishing PLC
Target group
Professional and scholarly
College/higher education
Dimensions
Height: 238 mm
Width: 160 mm
Thickness: 18 mm
Weight
500 gr
ISBN-13
978-1-5099-6718-6 (9781509967186)
Copyright in bibliographic data and cover images is held by Nielsen Book Services Limited or by the publishers or by their respective licensors: all rights reserved.
Schweitzer Classification
Person
Alexander Herman is Director of the Institute of Art and Law, UK.
Content
Introduction: A Matter Still Unresolved
1. From the Slopes of Mount Pentelikos
2. A Story with Neither Hero Nor Villain
3. A Firman by Any Other Name
4. Albion's Verdict
5. The History of a Claim
6. The (un)titled Masterpiece
7. Wellington and International Law
8. The View from Athens
9. Inside the British Museum
10. Resolving the Dispute
1. From the Slopes of Mount Pentelikos
2. A Story with Neither Hero Nor Villain
3. A Firman by Any Other Name
4. Albion's Verdict
5. The History of a Claim
6. The (un)titled Masterpiece
7. Wellington and International Law
8. The View from Athens
9. Inside the British Museum
10. Resolving the Dispute