Second-Class Saints
Black Mormons and the Struggle for Racial Equality
Published on 9. January 2025
Book
Hardback
488 pages
978-0-19-769571-5 (ISBN)
Description
An in-depth account--grounded in new archival discoveries--of the most consequential development in Mormon history since the end of polygamy
On June 9, 1978, the phones at the headquarters of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS) were ringing nonstop. Word began to spread that a momentous change in church policy had been announced and everyone wanted to know: was it true? The answer would have profound implications for the church and American society more broadly.
On that historic day, LDS church president Spencer W. Kimball announced a revelation lifting the church's 126-year-old ban barring Black people from the priesthood and Mormon temples. It was the most significant change in LDS doctrine since the end of polygamy almost 100 years earlier.
Drawing on never-before-seen private papers of LDS apostles and church presidents, including Spencer W. Kimball, Matthew L. Harris probes the plot twists and turns, the near-misses and paths not taken, of this incredible story. While the notion that Kimball received a revelation might imply a sudden command from God, Harris shows that a variety of factors motivated Kimball and other church leaders to reconsider the ban, including the civil rights movement, which placed LDS racial policies and practices under a glaring spotlight, perceptions of racism that dogged the church and its leaders, and Kimball's own growing sense that the ban was morally wrong.
Harris also shows that the lifting of the ban was hardly a panacea. The church's failure to confront and condemn its racial theology in the decades after the 1978 revelation stifled their efforts to reach Black communities and made Black members the target of racism in LDS meetinghouses. Vigilant members pestered church leaders to repudiate their anti-Black theology, forcing them to live up to the creed in Mormon scripture that "all are alike unto God." Deeply informed, engagingly written, and grounded in deep archival research, Harris provides a compelling and detailed account of how Mormon leaders lifted the priesthood and temple ban, then came to reckon with the church's controversial racial heritage.
On June 9, 1978, the phones at the headquarters of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS) were ringing nonstop. Word began to spread that a momentous change in church policy had been announced and everyone wanted to know: was it true? The answer would have profound implications for the church and American society more broadly.
On that historic day, LDS church president Spencer W. Kimball announced a revelation lifting the church's 126-year-old ban barring Black people from the priesthood and Mormon temples. It was the most significant change in LDS doctrine since the end of polygamy almost 100 years earlier.
Drawing on never-before-seen private papers of LDS apostles and church presidents, including Spencer W. Kimball, Matthew L. Harris probes the plot twists and turns, the near-misses and paths not taken, of this incredible story. While the notion that Kimball received a revelation might imply a sudden command from God, Harris shows that a variety of factors motivated Kimball and other church leaders to reconsider the ban, including the civil rights movement, which placed LDS racial policies and practices under a glaring spotlight, perceptions of racism that dogged the church and its leaders, and Kimball's own growing sense that the ban was morally wrong.
Harris also shows that the lifting of the ban was hardly a panacea. The church's failure to confront and condemn its racial theology in the decades after the 1978 revelation stifled their efforts to reach Black communities and made Black members the target of racism in LDS meetinghouses. Vigilant members pestered church leaders to repudiate their anti-Black theology, forcing them to live up to the creed in Mormon scripture that "all are alike unto God." Deeply informed, engagingly written, and grounded in deep archival research, Harris provides a compelling and detailed account of how Mormon leaders lifted the priesthood and temple ban, then came to reckon with the church's controversial racial heritage.
Reviews / Votes
A nuanced account of the Mormon church's uneven progress toward social justice. * Publishers Weekly * Second-Class Saints is a tour de force of historical research. It would be hard for me to overstate the importance of this book as well as my admiration for it. * Patrick Q. Mason, Arrington Chair Of Mormon History And Culture, Utah State University * This striking book deals with arguably the Mormon church's most challenging, enduring, and thorniest social and religious issue. Harris is superb at showcasing Black Mormons' efforts to overcome LDS leaders' bigotry. Second-Class Saints is a must-read for anyone hoping to increase their understanding of how the Mormon faith has produced dubious racial theories as well as Black Mormons' ongoing struggle for racial equity. * Cameron Mccoy, Author Of Contested Valor: African American Marines In The Age Of Power, Protest, And Tokenism * Offering fresh insights and drawing on untapped sources, Second-Class Saints provides an Unprecedented peek behind Mormonism's administrative curtain. Readers will discover New and sometimes painful stories that help to explain the faith's ongoing struggle to Transcend its racial past. * W. Paul Reeve, Author Of Religion Of A Different Color: Race And The Mormon Struggle For Whiteness * This painstakingly researched book tells the heart-rending history of Mormonism's race-based Priesthood and temple restrictions. In tracking the conflicts, constraints, and contingencies, The politics, pretexts, and planning, and the human actors who struggled for and against a more inclusive theology and church organization, Harris creates a powerful narrative - one that opens possibilities for healing in the present. * Rebecca De Schweinitz, Associate Professor Of History, Brigham Young University * Second-Class Saints is a masterful exploration of the Black struggle for racial equality within The LDS Church. Harris dissects the entrenched history of documented white supremacy Among church leadership and its theology, revealing a compelling, yet often overlooked, Chapter of religious history. * Darron T. Smith, Author Of Black And Mormon * Second-Class Saints by Matthew Harris should, if grappled with appropriately, force a reckoning... It will be impossible for anyone who reads it to be unaffected by what it clearly and irrefutably shows about the history of the priesthood and temple ban. * Ryan Ward, Association for Mormon Letters * A remarkable new book -- one of the best I've read in a long time. * Bill Tammeus, Faith Matters * A gripping, and often heartbreaking, read. * Jana Riess, Religious News Service * Harris has written the best and most digestible history of the debates and decisions that culminated in the end of the Latter-day Saint racial restriction. Any future histories on the topic will stand on Harris's shoulders. * Joseph R. Stuart, The Journal of Mormon History * This story will be riveting to New Mormon historians-itswealth of juicy detail will appeal as much as its argument. Harris has transformed a story of procedures into a story about people, and every bit of it illuminates the largely unspoken theoretical question of the definition of race, and its service as a theological, biological, or social category. * Matthew Bowman, Nova Religio * It is both well-researched and well-written. Readers will be richly rewarded for engaging with it. * James B. Bennett, Journal of Religious History * This is an excellent model for appropriate social history: extensively researched and documented, fairly interpreted, well written. Although not a general work on the topic, it is nevertheless crucial. * R. L. Saunders, Choice *More details
Language
English
Place of publication
New York
United States
Target group
College/higher education
Product notice
sewn/stitched
Cloth over boards
Illustrations
26 photos
Dimensions
Height: 239 mm
Width: 163 mm
Thickness: 37 mm
Weight
876 gr
ISBN-13
978-0-19-769571-5 (9780197695715)
Copyright in bibliographic data and cover images is held by Nielsen Book Services Limited or by the publishers or by their respective licensors: all rights reserved.
Schweitzer Classification
Other editions
Additional editions
E-Book
06/2024
OUP eBook
€33.99
Available for download
E-Book
06/2024
OUP eBook
€33.99
Available for download
Person
Matthew L. Harris is Professor of History at Colorado State University Pueblo, where he has taught since 2005. He specializes in race and religion, civil rights, Mormon history, African American history, legal history, and American religious history.
Content
Acknowledgements
Abbreviations
Introduction: Mormon Revelation
Chapter 1: From Policy to Doctrine, 1830--1949
Chapter 2: Racial Passing, 1949--1954
Chapter 3: Segregation, 1954--1962
Chapter 4: Civil Rights Resistance, 1962--1967
Chapter 5: Investigations and Protests, 1968--1970
Chapter 6: Lobbying for the Priesthood, 1970--1973
Chapter 7: Lifting the Ban, 1973--1978
Chapter 8: Debris in the Streets, 1978--1985
Chapter 9: The Stigma Still Goes On, 1985--2000
Chapter 10: Hard Doctrine, 2000--2013
Epilogue: Black (Mormon) Lives Matter, 2013--2023
Notes
Index
Abbreviations
Introduction: Mormon Revelation
Chapter 1: From Policy to Doctrine, 1830--1949
Chapter 2: Racial Passing, 1949--1954
Chapter 3: Segregation, 1954--1962
Chapter 4: Civil Rights Resistance, 1962--1967
Chapter 5: Investigations and Protests, 1968--1970
Chapter 6: Lobbying for the Priesthood, 1970--1973
Chapter 7: Lifting the Ban, 1973--1978
Chapter 8: Debris in the Streets, 1978--1985
Chapter 9: The Stigma Still Goes On, 1985--2000
Chapter 10: Hard Doctrine, 2000--2013
Epilogue: Black (Mormon) Lives Matter, 2013--2023
Notes
Index