Repairing British Politics
A Blueprint for Constitutional Change
Published on 17. February 2010
Book
Paperback/Softback
198 pages
978-1-84946-049-1 (ISBN)
Description
The constitutional crisis of 2009, sparked by the 'expenses scandal', led rapidly to the questioning of our entire political order. This book presents a major new constitutional analysis of the way we are governed. At the heart of the crisis lay an absence of accountability at the core of government. Repairing British Politics presents some key arguments for constitutional reform focused around a draft written Constitution underpinned by a new principle of constitutional supremacy. This would replace parliamentary sovereignty, which makes accountability more difficult. A written Constitution is not merely desirable; it is a constitutional necessity if Britain is to have true representative democracy. It would change our lives for the better by defining the over-arching values which we consider inviolable. The result would be a more rational, humane and inclusive society based on greater citizen involvement. Without a clear focus, constitutional reform will not happen. The approach taken here is therefore essentially practical and designed to provide a focal point around which a wider debate might be centred.
Written in an easily accessible style and including a Glossary of Essential Terms Repairing British Politics is intended as much for the intelligent general reader as for those professionally interested in law and politics. Part 1 sets out a number of arguments in favour of a written Constitution, as well as the most common objections. Part 2 presents a working draft in the form of one possible model for a Constitution. Observations and explanatory notes are attached to each section of this draft Constitution. This model Constitution is intended as the first stage in a public debate, designed to provoke further discussion about the content and method of legislating into law a written Constitution. Part 3 contains the draft of the Act of Parliament that would be needed to introduce any form of constitutional change. We are currently facing a crisis of trust in British politics. Whichever party forms the government the questions raised in Repairing British Politics will not go away.
Written in an easily accessible style and including a Glossary of Essential Terms Repairing British Politics is intended as much for the intelligent general reader as for those professionally interested in law and politics. Part 1 sets out a number of arguments in favour of a written Constitution, as well as the most common objections. Part 2 presents a working draft in the form of one possible model for a Constitution. Observations and explanatory notes are attached to each section of this draft Constitution. This model Constitution is intended as the first stage in a public debate, designed to provoke further discussion about the content and method of legislating into law a written Constitution. Part 3 contains the draft of the Act of Parliament that would be needed to introduce any form of constitutional change. We are currently facing a crisis of trust in British politics. Whichever party forms the government the questions raised in Repairing British Politics will not go away.
Reviews / Votes
Although the issue of a written constitution for the UK is not currently high on the political agenda, Gordon makes some interesting suggestions for constitutional change, some of which have been proposed by the coalition. Some, such as the fixed term for the House of Commons, have already been enacted. His observations and explanatory remarks contain some valuable insights. Practitioners and students of law and politics will find much of interest in this book. Jean McFadden SCOLAG Legal Journal Issue 409, November 2011 ...Richard Gordon's thoughtful contribution to the debate is both timely and worthy of very careful study. Repairing British Politics is a cautiously ambitious book: Gordon has gone to the considerable effort of drafting a constitution for the United Kingdom, and has even included a helpful glossary of terms at the beginning to help readers who are not lawyers or professional followers of politics...the real point of buying the book is the draft Constitution itself. It should be said at the outset that Gordon has produced an outstanding piece of constitutional scholarship in that he has codified a considerable amount of constitutional law and produced a coherent and comprehensive structure to both existing and new constitutional principles...It should also be noted that the Observations and Explanatory Notes Gordon provides after each part of the Constitution are immensely helpful in clarifying the thinking behind some of the choices made and the drafting used, and represent a real work of learning in themselves...Repairing British Politics does not contain all the answers and will not be the final word. It is not meant to be. But it will be impossible for anyone to seriously engage with the debate about moving to a written constitution without having digested and considered Richard Gordon's work. That is an achievement of which to be very proud. C.J.S. Knight Public Law Issue 3, July 2010 Richard Gordon's Book ... is a coherent and well constructed argument in favour of a written constitution. It is a succinct yet masterful combination of politics, philosophy, constitutional theory, law and history, accessible to lawyers and non-lawyers alike. It is a must read for anyone interested in the future of the UK constitution...Richard Gordon has initiated a timely and much needed debate in legal and political circles over the future of the UK constitution. He makes a reasoned and persuasive case on the need for change. Qudsi Rasheed JUSTICE Journal Volume 7, Number 1 ...the book is a must-read for anyone who wants to get a modern grip of our constitutional angst. Gordon's punchy 35-page scene-setting narrative and critique of our system of parliamentary supremacy (motif: nobody ever voted for it), should be mandatory reading for those who want to think about this issue properly. Ian Caplin Times Online May 6, 2010 The questions arising as to the proposals made mean that the value of the book is demonstrated: these are issues that all nations other than the UK, New Zealand and Israel have confronted and which are of such fundamental importance that they should be discussed. Gordon does so in an engaging and interesting manner, which provides a good starting point for the debate... Thoroughly recommended. Kris Gledhill NZ Lawyer April 2010 It is well written and contains sufficient detail to enable the reader to understand the reasons for the many suggestions which Mr Gordon makes...[An} excellent book... I would recommend it to any reader who, like myself, is interested in this topic and wishes to see our country with better constitutional arrangements than the present executive dominated parliament which claims to have absolute sovereignty. Obiter J 12th April 2010 In this work Gordon combines his expertise as a QC - specialising in administrative and public law and human rights - with an historical approach, to produce an argument about the need for change in the UK constitution, and a set of proposals about what it should become...it is informative and enjoyable to read, and fulfils its purpose well, in that it makes an effective case for a written constitution and could form a useful basis for discussions of what such an entity should comprise. I recommend it to anyone interested in the way we are governed, including those who (unlike myself) do not agree with its central arguments. Andrew Blick Open Democracy 19th March 2010 [an] interesting and thought-provoking book...Creative and imaginative thinking John Jackson Open Democracy 19th March 2010 This book will enable even those unfamiliar with the complexities of the current system to discuss, and formulate views about, the issues. Dawn Oliver International Journal of Law in Context Volume 6, Issue 4, 2010 [An] excellent example of the craft of the legal scholar and the political scientist [which] deserves close reading. Arthur Aughey Parliamentary Affairs January 7, 2011More details
Language
English
Place of publication
Oxford
United Kingdom
Publishing group
Bloomsbury Publishing PLC
Target group
Professional and scholarly
College/higher education
Dimensions
Height: 234 mm
Width: 156 mm
Thickness: 10 mm
Weight
0 gr
ISBN-13
978-1-84946-049-1 (9781849460491)
Copyright in bibliographic data and cover images is held by Nielsen Book Services Limited or by the publishers or by their respective licensors: all rights reserved.
Schweitzer Classification
Other editions
Additional editions
E-Book
02/2010
1st Edition
Hart Publishing
€29.99
Available for download
Person
Richard Gordon QC, a member of Brick Court Chambers, London, is recognised as one of the UK's leading silks in administrative and public law and human rights. He is a Visiting Professor at University College London and at the Chinese University of Hong Kong. He has acted in many of the most important public law and human rights cases in recent years, and appears regularly before the House of Lords and Court of Appeal and in foreign jurisdictions as well as before the ECJ and European Court of Human Rights.
Content
Acknowledgements Glossary of Essential Terms 1. SETTING THE SCENE Starting from Scratch Why We Need a Written Constitution Outline of the Book Power to the People The Origins of Parliamentary Sovereignty Cromwell and the UK's Two Written Constitutions No-one Ever Voted for Parliamentary Sovereignty Why Parliamentary Sovereignty Doesn't Work The Need for a Public Debate The Virtues of Representative Democracy Drafting a Written Constitution: The Practicalities Repairing British Politics: The Proposals Towards the Future 2. A DRAFT CONSTITUTION FOR THE UNITED KINGDOM Preamble Part 1: The State and the Constitution Part 2: Lawmaking Part 3: The House of Representatives Part 4: The Senate Part 5: Executive Government Part 6: Emergency Powers Part 7: Political Parties Part 8: The Judiciary Part 9: Fundamental Rights, Freedoms and Responsibilities Part 10: The Citizens' Branch Part 11: Other Aspects of Government Part 12: Constitutional Conventions Part 13: Constitutional Changes and Referendums Part 14: Interpretation and Final Matters 3. THE CONSTITUTION OF BRITAIN (REFERENDUMS) ACT Part 1: Referendum on a Written Constitution Part 2: Second Referendum on the Content of a Written Constitution Part 3: Implementation of the Second Referendum Part 4: Supplementary Schedules