Newspaper Confessions

Reviews / Votes

Golia...succeeds...[in] showing that advice columns deserve respect as a journalistic form and as a tool for community building in the modernizing United States....Golia's account offers a corrective for predominantly masculine narratives of journalism's professionalization. * John Nerone, Journal of American History * Nevertheless, the author presents a study that is extremely readable, which represents an enrichment for the postcolonial, gender and queer scientific perspective of media, culture and migration history and for further research on the intersectional contexts of readers of color , feminist and queer living environments in America in the first half of the 20th century. * Isabelle Haffter, Institute for Theater Studies, University of Bern, H-Soz-Kult von * American newspapers began targeting women readers in the 1890s as part of a transition from politically mobilizing readers to delivering consumers to advertisers....Newspapers soon offered a variety of columns on topics ranging from fashion and homemaking to relationships, helping readers navigate a changing society while upholding traditional gender norms. Syndicated columns ran in hundreds of newspapers across the country, and many metropolitan dailies established local columns that sought to create a sense of community among readers, inviting them to share their experiences and counsel. Advice column readers sought empathy, counsel, and a sense of community in an increasingly anonymous society. Golia concludes with a discussion of how social media and online communities have taken up this role today....Recommended. General readers through faculty; professionals. * Choice * This book would be useful in journalism and mass communication classes. * Kimberly Wilmot Voss, American Journalism * From Dorothy Dix to Princess Mysteria to Ann Landers, newspaper advice columnists have served as revenue drivers and cultural brokers, developing a democratic and interactive discourse in which women readers lay bare the practical as well as the existential challenges of modern life. In Julie Golia's fine book, these journalists craft self-identities that cloak their ambitions, exercise professional power, proffer advice that challenges as well as supports the status quo, and develop a genre that is as adaptable as it is therapeutic. * Jennifer Scanlon, Bowdoin College * Julie Golia's Newspaper Confessions is a terrific book. Full of interesting, at times eye-opening details and boasting a fascinating cast of characters, it sheds new light on a form of journalism that has been routinely disparaged, demonstrating its importance and revealing its influence on contemporary online communities. * Charles L. Ponce de Leon, author of Self-Exposure: Human-Interest Journalism and the Emergence of Celebrity in America * In this engaging study, Julie Golia illuminates how, when, and why Americans-especially women-began to seek advice for their most personal and intimate problems from total strangers writing in mass circulation newspapers. Newspaper Confessions not only traces the changing relationship between newspapers and their readers, but also uncovers the struggles confronting Americans of all backgrounds as they came to terms with modernity. * Elaine Tyler May, author of Homeward Bound: American Families in the Cold War Era * This book serves as an effective historical record of an area of journalism that may not be 'high status' in the way that the war reporter or undercover journalist might be considered, but through careful and detailed accounts of her evidence-base, Golia presents us with a wealth of testimony to the important role the advice column played in the twentieth century, providing insight into why it remains an enduring part of periodical journalism today. * Helena Goodwyn, Journal of European Periodical Studies *