Kant's Critique of Pure Reason and the Method of Metaphysics

Reviews / Votes

'This is an interesting, ambitious and hugely impressive work that concerns the crucial and under-explored question of the methodology at play in Kant's Critique of Pure Reason. Gava's careful and extensive analysis puts the relationship between Kant's notions of 'transcendental philosophy' and a 'critique of pure reason' in a new light, one that will be of interest to anyone working on Kant's metaphysics and epistemology today.' John Callanan, King's College London 'Throughout the book, Gava consistently asks and answers important questions about where in the Critique Kant takes on certain tasks, and how doing so serves Kant's overarching aim of establishing that metaphysics can become architectonic. Gava's detailed attention to the organization of the text, befitting of Kant's broadly scholastic roots, is often enlightening. What emerges is a compelling, coherent, and comprehensive account of the aims and composition of the entire Critique.' Charles Goldhaber, Journal of Transcendental Philosophy 'One of the great assets of Gabriele Gava's Kant's Critique of Pure Reason and the Method of Metaphysics is that it foregrounds a set of questions that stem directly from the Critique itself yet have attracted remarkably little attention. Rather than offering detailed accounts of much-debated issues such as Kant's idealism, realism, conceptualism, and the thing in itself, Gava focuses on the question as to why Kant proceeded the way he did and, more specifically, on the role of the Critiquein its capacity as doctrine of method of metaphysics. In so doing, Gava rightly gives pride of place to metaphilosophical concerns that most interpretations tend to marginalize. His monograph offers a holistic interpretation that presents core aspects of the Critique in a new light. Moreover, he rightly shifts the focus of attention from Kant's investigation into the a priori elements of experience to the question as to how metaphysics can be developed in a scientific manner.' Karin de Boer, Kantian Review 'I found Gava's book a thoughtful work that raises issues of interest to any reader of the Critique. The book is certainly not aimed specifically at students, and some of it will be challenging for those early in their study of Kant's work, but its account of the different stages of Kant's argument in the Critique will be helpful to them, particularly if its full implications are brought out by their teachers in the way that I have suggested. So this book is a welcome addition to the literature on the Critique of Pure Reason.' Paul Guyer, Studi Kantiani 'It is a work of excellent scholarship, clearly and persuasively presented. It has intelligent and original things to say about many of the central puzzles across the different parts of the CPR, as well as about the implications of that work for Kant's wider systematic philosophy. I think that anyone with a serious interest in Kant's philosophy should read it.' Robb Dunphy, International Journal of Philosophical Studies