The Law and Politics of Intervention in Federal Systems
Corrective or Coercive?
Edward Elgar Publishing
Published on 22. May 2026
Book
Hardback
342 pages
978-1-0353-4825-1 (ISBN)
Description
This interdisciplinary book explores the tension in federal systems between higher government level intervention and the autonomy of subnational and local governments. International experts examine a variety of jurisdictions across Africa, Asia, Europe and South America, illustrating how federal intervention can become a coercive tool for control rather than serving as a genuine corrective mechanism.
Adopting an international comparative approach, the contributing authors address how federal systems can undermine the self-governance rights of a territory and harm democracy, when they allow a senior level of government to intervene in the affairs of subnational and local authorities. Chapters cover vital questions about the extent of intervention that can and should be allowed and the conditions that justify and regulate these interventions. They examine the procedural safeguards available against unwarranted intervention, as well as how political dynamics influence the use, abuse and frequency of interventions.
The Law and Politics of Intervention in Federal Systems is an essential resource for students and academics in law and political science, particularly those interested in comparative constitutional law, comparative politics and, more specifically, comparative federalism.
Adopting an international comparative approach, the contributing authors address how federal systems can undermine the self-governance rights of a territory and harm democracy, when they allow a senior level of government to intervene in the affairs of subnational and local authorities. Chapters cover vital questions about the extent of intervention that can and should be allowed and the conditions that justify and regulate these interventions. They examine the procedural safeguards available against unwarranted intervention, as well as how political dynamics influence the use, abuse and frequency of interventions.
The Law and Politics of Intervention in Federal Systems is an essential resource for students and academics in law and political science, particularly those interested in comparative constitutional law, comparative politics and, more specifically, comparative federalism.
Reviews / Votes
'Through studies of ten federal and quasi-federal countries, this book delivers a valuable in-depth examination of the tensions between federalism's promise of regional and local democratic self-rule and interventions by federation and regional governments to ensure that regional and local governments maintain democracy, protect rights, behave honestly, deliver services, and fulfill constitutional duties while, in turn, seeking to prevent federation and regional governments from mounting corrupt and abusive interventions into regional and local affairs.' -- John Kincaid, Lafayette College, USAMore details
Series
Language
English
Place of publication
Cheltenham
United Kingdom
Target group
College/higher education
Professional and scholarly
Dimensions
Height: 234 mm
Width: 156 mm
ISBN-13
978-1-0353-4825-1 (9781035348251)
Copyright in bibliographic data is held by Nielsen Book Services Limited or its licensors: all rights reserved.
Schweitzer Classification
Persons
Edited by Yonatan T. Fessha, University of the Western Cape, South Africa and Karl Koessler,
Institute for Comparative Federalism of Eurac Research Bolzano/Bozen, Italy
Institute for Comparative Federalism of Eurac Research Bolzano/Bozen, Italy
Content
Contents:
1 The law and politics of intervention in federal systems:
framing the debate 1
Yonatan T. Fessha and Karl Koessler
2 Argentina: federal interventions as a constitutional way of
doing politics 13
Lara Goyburu
3 Brazil: federal intervention as a paradox of unity and autonomy 35
Marcelo Labanca Correa de Araujo
4 Ethiopia: the use and abuse of intervention powers 59
Zemelak Ayele and Gosaye Berhanu
5 India: President's Rule and permissive interventionism 87
Louise Tillin
6 Italy: federalism and intervention 115
Alice Valdesalici
7 Kenya: the framework and practice of national intervention in
counties 151
Henry Gichana
8 Malaysia: intervention under the guise of emergency powers? 170
Andrew Harding
9 Nigeria: continuity and change in the law and politics of
federal intervention 186
Rotimi Suberu
10 South Africa: the origins, uses and effectiveness of
intervention powers 216
Yonatan T. Fessha, Lisa Draga, and Jaap De Visser
11 Spain: the regulation and (rare) practice of central
government's intervention in the State of Autonomies 246
Ignacio Molina and Mayte Salvador
12 The balance between autonomy and intervention: lessons
from near and far 274
Nico Steytler
13 Intervention in federal systems: underlying rationales, legal
bases, procedures and politics 295
Karl Koessler and Yonatan T. Fessha
1 The law and politics of intervention in federal systems:
framing the debate 1
Yonatan T. Fessha and Karl Koessler
2 Argentina: federal interventions as a constitutional way of
doing politics 13
Lara Goyburu
3 Brazil: federal intervention as a paradox of unity and autonomy 35
Marcelo Labanca Correa de Araujo
4 Ethiopia: the use and abuse of intervention powers 59
Zemelak Ayele and Gosaye Berhanu
5 India: President's Rule and permissive interventionism 87
Louise Tillin
6 Italy: federalism and intervention 115
Alice Valdesalici
7 Kenya: the framework and practice of national intervention in
counties 151
Henry Gichana
8 Malaysia: intervention under the guise of emergency powers? 170
Andrew Harding
9 Nigeria: continuity and change in the law and politics of
federal intervention 186
Rotimi Suberu
10 South Africa: the origins, uses and effectiveness of
intervention powers 216
Yonatan T. Fessha, Lisa Draga, and Jaap De Visser
11 Spain: the regulation and (rare) practice of central
government's intervention in the State of Autonomies 246
Ignacio Molina and Mayte Salvador
12 The balance between autonomy and intervention: lessons
from near and far 274
Nico Steytler
13 Intervention in federal systems: underlying rationales, legal
bases, procedures and politics 295
Karl Koessler and Yonatan T. Fessha