An Ontological Rethinking of Identity in International Studies
Description
This book shows that identity studies in the discipline of International Relations (IR) generally cohere around two discrete understandings of being, substantialism and correlationism, and that their analytical, theoretical, and epistemological orientations are split along those lines. This binary opposition makes it difficult for identity scholarship to meet the internal validity standard of coherence while unnecessarily narrowing the theoretical lenses of constructivism in IR. The author argues that the best way to step outside that binary is to re-ground identity in ontology of immanence. The book shows that immanent ontological thinking enables us to have a pluralist epistemology and methodology for the study of identity, including both positivist and interpretivist orientations, without yielding a logically inconsistent alignment.
Reviews / Votes
"In this captivating book, Yong-Soo Eun makes the case for rethinking fixed and fluid identities in terms of "both-and" rather than "either-or." They are emergent processes grounded in an ontology of immanence. Thought-provoking theoretical discussions and rich empirical illustrations are brought together in an illuminating essay that is germane for all students of IR theory." ( Peter J. Katzenstein, Walter S. Carpenter Jr. Professor of International Studies, Cornell University, USA)"Eun Yong-Soo's ontological rethinking of identity in International Studies provides a fresh perspective on conventional and critical constructivist approaches to the subject. Moving beyond the either/or to the both/and, he re-grounds identity in a Deleuzian ontology of immanence. The book provides not only a beautifully written and concise typology of existing constructivisms, but also through an unpacking of components of European, Chinese and South Korean identities, a model for investigating identity construction in practice, which he further situates in a field that has tended to reify distinctions between West and non-West. The book is must reading for all who seek a way out of the current impasse and a richer understanding of what it might mean for IR to 'become rhizomatic.'" ( K.M. Fierke, Professor of International Relations, School of International Relations, St. Andrews, UK)
"Engaging Western constructivist theories, continental philosophy and East Asian sources, Yong-Soo Eun offers a new typology for understanding the role of identity in International Relations research. The ensuing insights advance important scholarly debates that have both conceptual and practical implications." ( Roland Bleiker, Professor of International Relations, University of Queensland, Australia)
More details
Other editions
Additional editions
Person
Yong-Soo Eun , Ph.D., is Professor of Political Science and International Studies at Hanyang University, Seoul, South Korea and the Editor-in-Chief of the Routledge series, IR Theory and Practice in Asia. Yong-Soo received his Ph.D. from the University of Warwick, UK. He is interested in IR theory, postcolonialism and decolonial thinking, Global IR, identity studies, and an ontology of immanence.
Content
Chapter 1: Introduction: A thorny problem.- Chapter 2: A typology of identity research in IR.- Chapter 3: Re-grounding identity in ontology of immanence.- Chapter 4: Illustrations and implications.