Defending the Realm?

Reviews / Votes

Counterinsurgency campaigns are too often analysed in the context of competing tactical approaches. Aaron Edwards focuses on the strategy and civil-military relations of post-World War II British counterinsurgency, making Defending the realm? an important and timely contribution to current debates on the challenges and costs of counterinsurgency.
Douglas Porch, Distinguished Professor of National Security Affairs at the Naval Postgraduate School, Monterey, California


A tour de force of modern British counterinsurgency, spanning over eight major campaigns since 1945 - Dr Aaron Edwards deserves congratulation for such meticulous research into each of these politically unique episodes. He has drawn on much material previously unpublished in his analysis of Britain's imperial decline and his focus on the political dimension rather than the military actualities of each campaign is refreshing. In all, Dr Edwards has provided an invaluable account of the differences between each and every British counterinsurgency campaign since 1945, explaining why they differed rather than attempting to develop yet another paradigm in counterinsurgency.
Col. David Benest, Former CO, 2 Para and former counter-insurgency advisor to the British Ambassador in Afghanistan

Aaron Edwards subjects Britain's experience of warfare against irregular enemies in 'small wars' since 1945 to the thorough strategic examination that it needs. While Defending the realm? tells the stories of eight 'small wars' in convincing detail, it does so very much with appropriate help from the guiding light provided by a firm grasp of the theory of strategy. Edwards' work is outstanding in its achievement of a successful marriage between history and strategic studies. He uses Clausewitz pervasively, though not intrusively or slavishly, as he insists on analysing the British strategic experience in its full political context. This is an exceptional book that must register as a major contribution to our understanding.
Professor Colin S. Gray, Department of Politics and International Relations, University of Reading

Edwards provides an invaluable account of the differences between each British counter-insurgency campaign since 1945, explaining why they differed rather than attempting to develop yet another paradigm of counter-insurgency.

A concise, readable text that should be of interest to students and scholars of British foreign policy, international relations, and security studies.

Edwards offers rich historical descriptions of important case-studies.

"In each of these case studies Edwards draws on a strong variety of appropriate sources. A selection of documents from different archives, autobiographies, newspapers, secondary literature and, in some cases, interviews have been used to good effect in these different studies. As Edwards explains, this volume covers a lot of historical material but does not aim to provide in-depth analysis of each study, although it does point the reader to other useful works. This approach is perhaps best demonstrated with the chapter on the British in Aden. This well-written and highly developed section is a promising insight into Edwards' future work on this topic."
(Philip R. Gannon, Political Studies Review Volume 12, Issue 3, September 2014) -- .