People As Subject, Object

Reviews / Votes

"This book is fascinating, enlightening, maddening, and disturbing [but] by the end one feels that Dominguez has, in fact, gotten to the bottom of what she convincingly argues is a condition for the very possibility of Israeli society-namely, the definition of peoplehood. . . . The two key concepts with which she deals throughout are 'culture' and 'ethnicity.' She analyzes newspaper accounts for both content and rhetoric or discourse on these subjects, and in addition, examines 'story-telling events' dealing with the lifestyles and situations of various Jewish minority groups-especially the Orientals or Sephardim-who have been only uneasily accommodated in Israeli society in recent years. 'Nationality' is distinguished both from 'religion' and from 'citizenship' in official Israeli usage, and Dominguez tries to analyze what this means for Israel as a polity, and as a community of persons who, in a cultural sense, have very little in common."-Nancie L. Gonzalez, American Anthropologist
|"Dominguez conveys much insight into the perception, attitudes, and contradictions of Israeli society. She effectively explains the internal and external boundaries of Israeli peoplehood and does surprisingly well with enormously confusing issues, such as 'who is a Jew?' The discussion of Israeli Independence Day, Sephardic/Ashkenazic ethnicity, and vignettes of theater and storytelling are especially worthy of mention. Her evaluation of the ongoing process of creating an Israeli national identity is outstanding."
-Choice
|"The best ethnography of Israeli Jews, collapsing the boundaries between tradition, culture, and nation. . . . Dominguez ambitiously focuses her fieldwork on processes that form the public discourses of national culture and that objectify and police individual and ethnic experiences through the national collectivity."-Smadar Lavie, Middle East Journal