Painted Prints

Reviews / Votes

"This fascinating catalogue offers a lucid introduction to a neglected yet basic phenomenon of printmaking. The field has been dominated by normative notions of prints as black and white and long assumed that the coloring of a print is somehow vulgar or a later and unwanted addition, supplied by insensitive collectors or unscrupulous dealers. Dackerman's study of coloring has the potential to shock us into a sharper consciousness of our inherited biases while also prompting us to look freshly and carefully at these beguiling prints."

-Larry Silver, Farquhar Professor, University of Pennsylvania "The hand-colored print has remained largely unmapped territory in the history of art. Both curators and historians of old master prints have tended to favor the graphic purity of black and white and are often reluctant to pronounce on the troublesome matter of whether coloring is original or added at a much later date. By tracing the history of this subject, Painted Prints makes an essential contribution to our knowledge of Northern Renaissance art. It is a history of taste and technique studied in context and with the aid of modern scientific analysis. The catalogue presents a judicious selection of objects loaned from many collections in America and abroad. The experience of these embellished images will enhance and thoroughly reorient our understanding of old master prints and their prior evaluation."

-Peter Parshall, Curator of Old Master Prints, National Gallery of Art "If Great Altarpieces punctures a modern prejudice about what a painting must look like, Painted Prints: The Revelation of Color (Pennsylvania State University Press, $35), the catalogue of a fascinating exhibition currently at the Baltimore Museum of Art, manages to shake up some very old assumptions about the nature of the graphic arts. Susan Dackerman begins with Erasmus's attack on the coloring of Duerer's prints, and suggests that this belief in the fundamental purity of black and white-which was reaffirmed some four hundred years later when Erwin Panofsky saluted Erasmus's view in his book on Duerer-has kept us from fully appreciating a whole range of chromatic possibilities. Dackerman's book is no mere postmodern reaction to what she seems to suggest is Panofsky's purism. She demonstrates that hand-coloring has been an integral element in printmaking since the fifteenth century. Beginning with the attractively rough-and-ready patches of hue that were applied to fifteenth-century woodcuts, Dackerman pursues the subject all the way to the seventeenth century and Hercules Seger's exquisitely tinted landscape etchings. Painted Prints shows us the many ways in which applied color has been set in a rich, frequently subtle, and complex dynamic with the monochrome of the print."

-Jed Perl, The New Republic "Dackerman and Primeau deserve our warm thanks for restoring an entire category of prints to our history of these media and for opening our eyes to the startling and striking qualities of a neglected phenomenon."

-Larry Silver, CAA Reviews "This catalog accompanies an intriguing exhibit of painted Northern Renaissance and Baroque prints mounted by the Baltimore Museum of Art (BMA) and then moving to St. Louis. Dackerman, who is a curator at BMA, and Thomas Primeau, a conservator there, present an intriguing overview of the hand application of paint after black-and-white prints were made. . . . Their provocative and unique thesis is that these prints have not been appropriately valued by later sensibilities, which hold more highly the aesthetics of black-and-white prints, and that the hand-colored prints deserve to be reevaluated."

-Kathryn Wekselman, Library Journal "This exhibition catalog, gorgeously and lavishly illustrated, presents the argument that coloring, even with stencils, was distinctly not declasse, particularly in Germany during the 16th century. . . . Beautifully produced, the book will remain useful long after the exhibition's run because the research it presents challenges our normal ways of thinking about the early maturity of printmaking."

-P. Emison, CHOICE "Beautifully produced, the book will remain useful long after the exhibition's run because the research it presents challenges our normal ways of thinking about the early maturity of printmaking."

-P. Emison, CHOICE "Dackerman and her colleagues are nonetheless to be highly commended for opening up new and colorful vistas on the world of early modern prints."

-Donald McColl, Historians of Netherlandish Art Newsletter