Divine Service?

Reviews / Votes

'The history, as well as the structure and function, of Israel's Armed Forces, is characterized by many riddles. Not the least of them is the question of how did the '"people of the Book" turn into a "nation in arms"? This scholarly book sheds light on this and many other paradoxes existing presently in the Israeli military.' Reuven Gal, Founding Chair of The Israeli Association for Civil-Military Studies 'Stuart A. Cohen is Israel's leading student of civil-military relations, and he has long written with great insight, and often provocatively, on the ever-changing place of religion in the army of the Jewish state. This wide-ranging and elegantly-written collection shows how unique Cohen is in bringing together deep knowledge of the Israel Defense Forces, mastery of the Jewish tradition, and sensitivity to the contemporary Israeli scene. A must-read for those concerned about the past, present, and future not only of the IDF, but of Israel.' Ronald R. Krebs, University of Minnesota, USA 'Stuart Cohen, a full professor at Israel's Bar Ilan University, and who recently became the head of the Politics and Governance department at the Academic College of Ashkelon, is not only one of Israel's leading civil-military relations scholars, but perhaps the leading academic authority on halachah scholarship on warfare. He has produced a concise, comprehensive, reader-friendly introduction to the Israeli case study... an authoritative and comprehensive work... Overall, it is a magnum opus, since he manages to summarise decades of work and provide an unrivalled introduction to an important topic.' Defense and Security Analysis 'Thorough in its sources, lucid in its presentation, and balanced in its analysis, this text brings together some of Cohen's most influential publications as well as novel work. ... This responsa literature is Cohen's greatest area of expertise, and he offers a broad survey and a careful evaluation of prominent texts in that literary 'An introduction that weaves together all three parts of the anthology, as well as an epilogue that addresses the vexing problem of Haredi (non)enlistment in the IDF and its implications for Israeli society, round out the volume, whose rich contents have barely been scratched in this brief review. Suffice it to say here that Cohen's anthology is a most important contribution to the field of military sociology in respect of the IDF, and, as such, it deserves a very wide audience.'

David Rodman, Israel Affairs