Debating Southern History

Reviews / Votes

This rich array of documents and insightful essays by two esteemed southern historians make this a lively introduction to the multiple minds and voices of the South that paved the way for the dramatic transformation of the region in the post-World War II era. A valuable classroom resource that students should find as engaging as their instructors. -- John C. Inscoe, University of Georgia Clayton and Salmond have written extensive essays-clear, insightful, sweeping-that capture much of the pain and promise (particularly in the area of race) of twentieth century southern life. -- Frederick Hobson, University of North Carolina Bruce Clayton and John Salmond's essays in Debating Southern History compellingly reveal the intellectual and reform currents of a briskly changing twentieth-century South. The authors convincingly show how modernist trends inspired creativity, dissent, and renewal among both white and black writers and activists-some of them quite famous like William Faulkner and Martin Luther King and others undeservedly obscure. Skillfully the essays explore the subtle interplay between African-American and white, liberal thought and action. Debating Southern History deserves a widespread and long-sustained popular readership. -- Bertram Wyatt-Brown, author of <I>The Shaping of Southern Culture<I> With Bruce Clayton focusing on the intellectual and literary ferment in the South from the 1920s through the 1960s and John Salmond taking as his subject the labor, political, and racial components of the same era, this volume offers a fascinating examination of the most important period of 20th century southern history. Carefully selected documents following each essay enrich the volume. -- Robert Durden, Duke University Debating Southern History underscores the vital nexus between ideology and social and political change in the modern South. With insightful analysis and illustrative documents, Clayton and Salmond chart the South's slow and circuitous path to political and social justice. Ideal for students at all levels. -- John David Smith, professor, The University of North Carolina at Charlotte; author of An Old Creed for the New South In their often eloquent and vividly detailed essays, Bruce Clayton and John Salmond present astute and intellectually provocative analyses of the South from the depression through the civil rights movement. The accompanying documents are well-chosen-some for their manifest significance, others for their rare insights into historical events. Debating Southern History makes an original, thoughtful, and convincing contribution to the understanding of the region and its meaning for American history in the twentieth century. -- Charles Joyner, Coastal Carolina University Bruce Clayton and John Salmond have produced two beautifully written essays accompanied by carefully selected documents. Clayton weaves together the ideas of well-known and of comparatively little-known writers to form the most comprehensive analysis of the thought of the 20th Century South that I have ever read. Salmond matches Clayton's analysis with a thoughtful and well written essay on the South in the Depression and Post-depresssion years. He shows how "southern activists" involved in the labor movement and the struggle for civil rights challenged the "southern caste system." A unique and informative book. -- Richard L. Watson, Jr., Duke University This book is another marvelous contribution from Rowman and Littlefield's 'Debating 20th Century America' series. The two essays complement one another in interesting and revealing ways. On the whole, then, this is a fine little book. It deserves to be used in advanced undergraduate and graduate classrooms. The essays are very well crafted, readable, thorough, and sophisticated. There is a wonderful discussion going on in Debating Southern History and it deserves to be widely read. * H-Net: Humanities and Social Science Reviews Online * The pairing of ideas with action is intriguing, the individual essays well explicated and complementary without being redundant, and the sources are both relevant and enjoyable reading. * North Carolina Historical Review *