Collision of Worlds

Reviews / Votes

A thorough, balanced, and nuanced view of the Spanish invasion and conquest of Mesoamerica and the establishment of colonial New Spain.... This book not only helps us to better understand the centuries-long experiences in New Spain but also illustrates how weaving together multiple histories, at both macro- and micro-levels, can provide insights about culture contact-the collision of worlds-and its analysis. * Janine Gasco, American Anthropologist * Well researched, up-to-date, and even-handed, Collision of Worlds is a much-needed retelling of the Aztec overthrow, giving due weight to archaeological findings and indigenous sources, especially those written in Nahuatl by eyewitnesses who let us see into the Mexican side of a complex tragedy long told from mostly European viewpoints. * Ronald Wright, Times Literary Supplement * We have long needed just such a book, and I imagine that for many years historians will consult this volume whenever they need to understand more about archaeology's contributions to the study of early Mexico. * Camilla Townsend, Hispanic American Historical Review * Illuminating and richly detailed, this fascinating history shows readers that worlds are not lost; tendrils of what has gone before intertwine with, fashion, and forever mark the hybrid societies of today. * Historical Novel Society * I so recommend David M. Carballo's dazzling and masterful book on the Aztecs and the Spanish, their similarities and differences. * Simon Sebag Montefiore, Aspects of History * David Carballo has given us 'two for one' in this deep history of the great encounter of Spain and Mesoamerica that forged the Mexico of today. Rather than limit his focus on the dynamic five-year period between the arrival of Spaniards in 1517 and the fall of the Aztec capital of 1521, this book is a monumental work of long range historical and archaeological comparison of ethnicities, myths, cities, markets, world views, and human actions. No other history of the war for the Aztec capital reveals the cultural depth or historical breadth of what was truly at stake when the Aztec ruler Cuauhtemoc yielded to Cortes at the pyramids of Tlatelolco in August of 1521. * David Carrasco, author of The Aztecs: A Very Short Introduction * David Carballo weaves a fascinating historical tapestry. Collision of Worlds is authoritative, evenhanded, and draws on a broad array of sources. This outstanding account helps us understand the roots of today's globalized world. * Brian Fagan, author of The Little Ice Age * Collision of Worlds takes a new look at the world-changing events of 1519-1521 and the Spanish invasion of Mexico. Archaeologist David Carballo examines two landscapes * Medillin, Spain, home of Hernando Cortes, and Cholula, Mexico dominated by its Great Pyramidto illustrate the entanglements of deep history and place that shaped New Spain and the foundations of the global world.Deborah Nichols, coeditor of The Oxford Handbook of the Aztecs * Collision of Worlds is a unique and resonant achievement, an old story told in a new way. By adopting an archaeologist's perspective, David Carballo is able to offer a fresh and thought-provoking take on the history of the Spanish-Aztec encounter. And by reaching back into the deep Mesoamerican and Iberian pasts, he helps us to better understand that encounter, its outcomes, and its significance. * Matthew Restall, author of When Montezuma Met Cortes * In this remarkable work of comparative history and archaeology, David Carballo situates the Spanish-Mexica wars of the 16th century within a parallel account of Iberia and Mesoamerica, stretching back into humanity's deep past. * David Wengrow, author of What Makes Civilization? * Carballo's use of the textual archive is a welcome complement to archaeological evidence and material objects...he rightfully relies on historical narratives from late sixteenth- and early seventeenth-century castizo and mestizo authors who petitioned the Spanish courts for recognition as the descendants of Indigenous allies who supported the Spanish troops in the conquest. * Carlos Macias Prieto, Early American Literature *