South Africa's 1994 election was widely hailed around the world as miraculous. In this book, Anthony Butler examines South African experiences to cast doubt on this celebratory attitude to democracy. Contemporary political analysis highlights the benefits that democracy can sometimes bring. Butler, by contrast, argues that democracy can be malign. He attacks the myth that democracy ended apartheid, and shows that democratic practices themselves contributed to its evils. The author also explores weaknesses in political science as a discipline. This book will be essential reading for specialists in South Africa, and will appeal to political theorists, students of comparative politics, and historians.
Reviews / Votes
'This is a powerful exposition of the ways in which conventional categories of political analysis, liberal and local, have both influenced events in South Africa in the 1990s and misunderstood them. Theorists have perpetuated continuities that have in fact been broken and argued for discontinuities that are less striking than they seem. It will be essential reading for students of South Africa itself and those who suppose that the extension of 'democracy' in the 1990s is an unequivocal advance.' - Geoffrey Hawthorn, University of Cambridge
'Dr Butler's book is a closely argued study of the nature of political enquiry, focusing on the modes of analysis employed by western scholars and their South African counterparts in their exploration of South Africa's past and present. It will provoke keen debate and provide a source of valuable insight into the nature of liberal democracy and the incentives and constraints that attend the construction of social and political theory.' - Professor J. E. Spence, Associate Fellow, Royal Institute of International Affairs
'...an important work on South African scholarship of wide interest to scholars and policy makers...required reading for the South African specialist. The fact that it organizes a vast literature on South Africa is also likely to prove very useful in graduate teaching.' - Henrik Sommer, Nationalism & Ethnic Politics
Edition
Language
Place of publication
Target group
Professional and scholarly
Product notice
sewn/stitched
Cloth over boards
Illustrations
Dimensions
Height: 216 mm
Width: 140 mm
Thickness: 16 mm
Weight
ISBN-13
978-0-333-66593-0 (9780333665930)
DOI
Schweitzer Classification
ANTHONY M. BUTLER was educated at St. Anne's College, Oxford, and King's College, Cambridge. He was a Research Fellow of Emmanuel College, Cambridge. He is Lecturer in Politics at the University of Nottingham, and author of the
Transformative Politics: The Future of Socialism in Western Europe
, this was described by Andrew Gamble as 'A major contribution to the rethinking of the socialist project. The analysis is clear and profound and identifies the dilemmas but also the potential of contemporary socialism'.
Preface Introduction A Periodization of South African History Historical Debates and Political Analysis Democracy and Apartheid Analysing Democratic Transitions Political Science and the End of Apartheid The Failure of Political Science Conclusions Bibliography Index
