The Legal Mind

Reviews / Votes

'Broz?ek takes us on an absorbing journey into the nature of reasoning, using the courtroom and its legal framework as a particularly revealing case study. The result is a highly original perspective on an old set of problems. The book is clear, fresh and insightful, as well as remarkably practical. It targets not just lawyers and logicians, but anyone who wonders how they figure things out.' Patricia Churchland, University of California, San Diego 'The Legal Mind is a well-written, highly engaging and uniquely innovative contribution to legal research. It provides afresh account of legal cognition, based on the integration of cognitive science, legal theory, and philosophy. Contemporary theories of mind provide a vantage point to examine how different human faculties (intuition, insight, imagination, emotion, language, abstraction, theorisation, logic) interact in legal cognition. Past and present approaches to legal reasoning and interpretation are critically reassessed, and linked to the new approach developed in the book. Strongly recommended for lawyers, legal theorists, and law students interested in expanding the awareness of what it means to know and apply the law.' Giovanni Sartor, University of Bologna 'The Legal Mind is a comprehensive, historically informed, and original portrait of law and legal thinking. Clear and engaging in style, international in focus, and examining cases from many countries and contexts, it presents insights from law, philosophy, and cognitive science. It also engages many legal, moral, and philosophical theories, clarifies legal reasoning, and overcomes misleading dichotomies - between reason and emotion, the analytic and the imaginative, and the top-down and bottom-up in legal thinking. This book holds great interest for readers not only in legal areas but also in philosophy or other fields.' Robert Audi, John A. O'Brien Professor of Philosophy, University of Notre Dame 'I recommend Brozek's book The Legal Mind. It is a unique blend of traditional legal theory and modern cognitive science and shows how insights from cognitive science can be used to address issues in the theory of legal decision-making. In this way, it contributes to the field of legal decision-making, that seemed to be outworn but with a book like this receives a refreshing new impulse. At the same time it contributes to cognitive science by showing how the insights from that blossoming science are also applicable in an area that was until recently dominated by a rather theoretical and abstract discourse on theories of interpretation. This fusion of legal theory and modern cognitive science is the main added value of this volume, a value which is only increased by the analytical rigour of the analyses and the background support from traditional philosophy.' Jaap Hage, Chair for Jurisprudence, Maastricht University 'Legal epistemology is an evergreen topic in jurisprudence. The number of telling accounts on the subject has grown exponentially over the past few years. Offering an original analysis in such a crowded field of literature is no easy task. Yet, this is exactly what Bartoz Brozek has managed to do ... and he ought to be praised for that. A prolific writer, Brozek in The Legal Mind has drawn from his vast and deep-rooted philosophical, cognitive, and behavioural science knowledge to shed new light on what legal reasoning and understanding really are and how they operate.' Luca Siliquini-Cinelli, The Edinburgh Law Review