Modern Rome

Reviews / Votes

"Depicting and explaining the development of the 'modern' Rome, from Napoleon's urban planning laws in 1811 until the contemporary urban development, the book provides in-depth, informed and comprehensive insight into the complex socio-political, cultural and economic conditions that shaped spatial reality, in the same time leading the reader through the phases of Rome's urban history with astonishing ease. Strongly supported by the classic work of Italo Insolera, one of the leading scholars in historical urban studies, this masterpiece illustrates the growth of the modern Rome with precious detail, pointing to both successful saving of its past from destruction, as well as the elements of chaotic urban growth. [By] reflecting on the past episodes of Rome's urban planning, the book also provides the guidelines on future urban development crucified between the need for heritage protection, challenges of multiethnicity and trends of global capitalism. Written in a language free of professional jargon, the book is valuable reading material."Gerd Albers Award "Best Book" 2019 by the International Society of City and Regional Planners (ISOCARP)"The book's major contribution lies in the abundant, exhaustive and accurate information provided in the description of urban phenomena. It is an ordered account that covers the most important aspects of the history of modern urban planning in Rome whilst not neglecting to describe the complexity underlying any metropolitan urban process. The author accepts the cultural, social and political spheres as realities that are inextricably linked to each other and, in turn, to the city's spatial transformation. [...] The writing [...] lies somewhere between history and memory: between bibliographical study and remembrance, historical event and lived experience. While descriptions based on bibliographical documentation prevail in the analyses of nineteenth-century phenomena, as the author progresses through the twentieth century, an analysis of phenomena filtered by knowledge of lived experience becomes apparent. However, he is impeccable in overcoming the difficulty of giving continuity to this personal reality: when the author has to analyse himself, he chooses to give up the limelight, avoiding any self-referential citation as much as possible, despite having been a relevant voice at different moments of the city."David Escudero, Universidad Politecnica de Madrid, SpainUrban Research & Practice, Vol. 13, 2020, Issue 2"Rome is not just another urban agglomeration. For centuries, even millennia, it defined what a city should be. Its powerful allure should offer precious lessons to city planners and place-makers, which is why the supple translation into English of Italo Insolera's classic Roma Moderna is such a welcome event. Urban planning in Rome has never been a smooth process. [...] With the Roman elite and the Vatican itself pursuing profit through unregulated development, Insolera's account [...] could make for melancholy reading. And yet his tale is a compelling one, because progress was made, even if only in fits and starts. Insolera's attention to how urban planning, or its absence, affected the humbler classes is evident throughout Modern Rome. [...] Insolera laments 'the annihilation of planning' after 1990. He nonetheless kept alive a high sense of what might give Romans a better urban experience, despite the haphazard quality of the city's daily governance. Here, as throughout this generous chronicle, he focuses on both material and cultural improvements."Barringer FifieldUrbanities, Vol. 10, No. 2, 2020"The transformation of the historical centre is also charted, with the extensive demolitions carried out between the late nineteenth century and the Fascist period, and then the processes of tertiarization, gentrification and touristification that have profoundly altered its structure and function since the mid-twentieth century. Among [the peculiarities of Rome's urban development is] [...] the exceptional extent of unauthorized construction, which in the 1970s 'was no longer one among Rome's facts of life; rather, it became the city's very way of being.' [...] Roma moderna has been for decades compulsory reading for anybody approaching the urban history of Rome from Italian unification to the present. It has also been a highly influential book: numerous scholars and observers have embraced and developed Insolera's perspective and interpretations. In the last 20 years [...] some [...] urban historians have proposed new approaches and/or provided more detailed [...] accounts of various aspects of the history of twentieth-century Rome. [...] [T]his does not alter the fact that this translation into English of a veritable classic of Italian urban history is certainly praiseworthy."Bruno BonomoSapienza Universita di RomaUrban History, Volume 47, Issue 4, 2020"Unlike Paris, London and Vienna, which were profoundly altered during the earlier part of the nineteenth century, papal Rome had retained its old structure and appearance, substantially unmodified since the late Baroque period, and still contained within the walls built by Emperor Aurelian (270-275 CE). [...] From this moment onward, Rome's urban development took place in ways that break the city's continuity with its past. It is a growth that excludes and leaves behind most of the city's residents, then and in the years to come; that is oblivious to the city's centuries-old traditions and constitutive features, and incapable of building and passing on a coherent image from one generation to the next: a growth ultimately unable to 'conceive of planning as a means to build a society.' [...] In spite of all that, Modern Rome sends a cautious message of hope. It looks at the common threads that underlie the city's trajectory over time and sees 'culture and art as the key elements from which future Rome may eventually draw new reinvigorating life and meaning'."Francesco SiravoLink Campus University of Rome; Journal of Urban Design, March 2021"The book, while constituting an essential contribution to the urban history of Rome, is also a crucial reading for scholars interested in a broader understanding of Italian national history, and in particular its complex, ambiguous and contradictory relationship with modernity. [...] The evolution of the book itself provides powerful evidence of the involution of Italy, and illuminates some of the core reasons for Italy's persisting crisis, including the responsibilities of those centre-left parties and local and national governments that, despite many promises, largely failed to promote the modernisation of Rome, and of the whole country. [...] The reader will be left wondering what Rome could have been, had its promise of modernity not been so remarkably neglected. Yet what makes Rome unique and beautiful is also its palimpsestic, chaotic, fragmented, cynical, contradictory and iconic character. The book provides an idealistic, detailed and critical analysis of a capital city that failed to embrace not just modern, rational and progressive urban planning, but perhaps modernity itself."Francesco RicattiMonash University; Modern Italy, Volume 26, Issue 1, February 2021"Nonetheless, he persevered to illuminate urban Rome's complex modern evolution through the emergence of this flawed, desired, noble, disordered, and continuously changing icon of the ancient past. In this, the resonance of the author's true voice makes the dense volume enjoyable to read. He produced what he characterizes as a tragi-comic portrayal of unauthorized dwellings later amnestied, failed big initiatives, including the missed opportunities for major parks along the Via Appia Antica and the Roman Fora still dominated by Mussolini's Via Fori Imperiali, and unresolved traffic infrastructure, leaving him to question whether Rome can even claim to be a modern city. [...] Noting that Rome has been a city of immigrants characterized by many ethnicities, faiths, and cultures for all of its long history as a civilization justifies its current growth by accretion. Due to a declining birthrate, Rome's augmented population is primarily through diverse immigration [...] This is a most humanizing catalyst for consideration. The influx to Rome is largely young and educated, and newcomers contribute to the livelihood of the metropolis."Kay Bea JonesOhio State University; Journal of Planning Education and Research, Volume I-3, August 2020