Architecture Beyond Experience

Reviews / Votes

"A compelling and beautiful book, full of insights. How is architecture humanistic and post-humanistic at once? What is the agency of objects, sentient creatures, and buildings? Using Martin Buber's notions of 'I-It' and 'I-You' and Michael Graziano's theory of consciousness, Benedikt articulates a lucid attack on the solipsism behind architecture's participation in the Experience Economy. From isovists to the 'fabric of glances, ' 'm-branes, ' and 'presence fields, ' the inventor of 'isovists' and 'isovist fields' crafts intricate webs based on visual connections among rooms, objects, and people. Architecture Beyond Experience presents a refreshing view of architecture as dialogical and relational, giving priority to the life of buildings as well as to the life of the people inside and around them." --Sophia Psarra, University College London, author of The Venice Variations: Tracing the Architectural Imagination "A Copernican Revolution in architecture is accomplished in this book, relocating the experiencing subject--today's assumed center of gravity--into a constellation of non-concentric orbits, connections, and alignments that are equally social, spatial, and environmental, which is to say architectural. As engaging as it is erudite, the text adduces evidence from domains we tend to keep apart--religion, perceptual psychology, and philosophy for example--in order to deepen our understanding of architectures we thought we knew, works by figures like Aldo van Eyck, Louis I. Kahn, Carlo Scarpa, and Le Corbusier, as well as some of our contemporaries, Frank Gehry especially. Humanist in its ethics, although post-human in its approach, this book is delightfully readable, unquestionably profound, and strikingly original." --David Leatherbarrow, University of Pennsylvania, author of Architecture Oriented Otherwise "Benedikt's provocatively titled book is an important and timely argument against 'experiential' architecture, which is designed to stimulate unique and personal experiences, and for 'relational' architecture, which is designed to foster relations among the people who inhabit it. Benedikt focuses on what buildings do to affect and engender relationships, and on how rooms are first and foremost the settings for encounters with others. By calling our attention to the 'fabric of glances' that occurs in any room with more than one occupant, Benedikt artfully reminds us that the relationships and interactions that take place within architecture are its principle reason-for-being." --Robert McCarter, Washington University in St. Louis, author of The Space Within: Interior Experience as the Origin of Architecture "Michael Benedikt has long helped us understand how buildings frame co-visibility and, by implication, the ways in which we interact with others. Here he argues that if the spaces of a building have integrity of form and construction, if they communicate their relationship to each other as deliberately as they do their individual constitution, then they are more likely to support bonds between people that are more deeply felt and more formative of character than purely instrumental. This philosophically fundamental assertion becomes all the more compelling for being presented through new descriptive concepts, beautiful analytical diagrams, and carefully selected case studies. Architecture Beyond Experience is a courageous and sparklingly original book, one that affirms the power of architecture to go beyond the production of novel images and even memorable experiences to embody the moral and aesthetic underpinnings of our relationships to each other and the physical world." --John Peponis, Georgia Institute of Technology, co-founder and leading scholar of 'space syntax' "Michael Benedikt has travelled far to communicate the ancient, animistic dialogue of I-You as it occurs in the 'person' of Architecture, in the secret life of buildings. Architecture Beyond Experience is a profoundly scholarly and ethically unselfish work. Architecture's epistemological foundations, Benedikt argues, are found neither in its technical facticity nor in its staging of experiences, but in its fictional salutations, whispered and overheard." --Peter Waldman, University of Virginia, author of Lessons from the Lawn: The Word Made Flesh: Dialogs Between Citizens and Strangers "On rare occasions a book comes along that moves our thinking about the built environment in a new direction, and Architecture Beyond Experience is such a book. In an era in which architecture has become a part of the "experience economy" (as well as the concentration-of-wealth economy), Michael Benedikt reminds us that the built environment is not just about private aesthetic experiences, but about social ethical relations--among things and rooms as well as people. What matters is not what a building says of or does for me, but what a building says of or does for all, including itself by way of example." --Thomas Fisher, University of Minnesota, author of The Architecture of Ethics "This exhilarating journey through recent architectural theory shuns the self-indulgent solipsism to which phenomenological approaches often fall prey, as well as the wilder speculations of 'object orientation.' In going 'beyond experience, ' Benedikt paradoxically offers a new and deeper understanding of experience: rather than being the prime object and outcome of architectural design endeavors, experience is allowed to emerge as a property of the relations being acted out between works of architecture themselves, their components, and the bodies and behaviors they house." --Jonathan Hale, University of Nottingham, author of Merleau-Ponty For Architects "This momentous publication transcends the narrow framing of phenomenology in architecture as the domain of enriching spatio-sensory stimulation in the cause of augmenting personal experience, in order to reach for phenomenology's neglected communicative aspect: the realm of interpersonal relations. It does this marvelously with an enlarged, quasi-animistic definition of what a 'person' is, a 'thing' is, and a 'room' is. The book is highly enlightening in its treatment of philosophers of the interpersonal, such as Martin Buber, as well as in its treatment of certain art movements, such as performance art and Mono Ha. It presents novel objects of study for designers, such as 'isovists, ' 'the fabric of glances, ' 'm-branes, ' and 'the order of shoulders, ' and it ends by providing new understandings of certain canonical modern buildings--buildings the simple experience of which was always only a beginning." --Jin Baek, Seoul National University, author of Architecture as the Ethics of Climate "Whereas most architectural theories consist of the pounding on a single drum, with Architecture Beyond Experience Michael Benedikt strikes up the entire orchestra, artfully weaving metaphysics and everyday life, broad theory and its practical applications, old wisdom and current empirical science to pursue the question of what a humanist, yet post-anthropocentric architecture might look like in the twenty-first century. Benedikts thesis? We are relational creatures from the get go, and it is in the creation of relationships that architecture holds its greatest sources of power, agency--and wonder. While this may be easy to state, to convincingly and nuancedly describe how it works is another matter. This is where Benedikt excels. By lucidly painting a paradigm, by providing us with a vocabulary and an open, generative theory, this may be the book weve been waiting for to mark architectures turn away from its current servants role in the experience economy toward something more deserved." --Michael Merrill, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology, author of Louis Kahn: Drawing to Find Out "Wow--what a book! Benedikt builds on his impressive work on architectural realism, deconstruction, cyberspace, value, creativity, and ethics with a timely, 'post-phenomenological' treatise on the magic of design. In Architecture Beyond Experience, he casts buildings as sentient beings and rooms as relational subjects that crackle with social electricity. Rejecting the enticements of the neoliberal experience economy, Benedikt instead poses ontological empathy as the most effective (and affective) way for architects to operate humanely in a burgeoning posthuman world." --Jon Yoder, Kent State University, author of Widescreen Architecture: Immersive Media and John Lautner