Disputing Disaster

Reviews / Votes

The most erudite and compelling voice on the British Marxist left ... Disputing Disaster is a book unlike any other on the 1914 debate ... a wealth of sharp and compelling reflections on how and why historians argue as they do, why they rethink, abandon or double down on their positions, and how politics and emotion flow into the writing of history and back out of it into the world. -- Christopher Clark * London Review of Books * One of the best political, historical and literary essayists of the age. * Times Literary Supplement * [A] provocative exploration of overlooked causes of a war that may or may not have been a historical inevitability. * Kirkus Reviews * Remarkably erudite ... a book of immense learning and interest that should be read by everyone with an interest in the history of the Great War -- Simon Heffer * Sunday Telegraph * Punchy but wide-ranging ... Anderson's treatment of the literature is characteristically deft and learned -- Nicholas Mulder * Financial Times * Readers who are new to the debate will find it interesting to see how many different histories of the same event came to [be] written. Those who are already familiar with the authors discussed here will find plenty that is fresh and surprising in Anderson's use of personal papers and archival sources in many different languages. -- Annika Mombauer * Literary Review * Perry Anderson is one of Britain's most brilliant historians, a penetrating political analyst and a vigorous intellectual combatant. Hence, it's no surprise that Disputing Disaster, his discussion of the history wars over the origins of World War I, is a lively and fascinating read. -- Daniel Lazare * Arts Fuse * Scintillant, conceptually resourceful, and idiosyncratically elegant ... a phenomenal exercise in synoptic thinking. -- Leo Robson * New Statesman * World War I gave rise to a heated century-long debate about its causes. In Disputing Disaster, Perry Anderson surveys this wide-ranging field and makes the case that the Great War cannot be understood without considering the role of imperialism. -- Mathias Fuelling * Jacobin * A remarkable consideration of how historians understand war -- Hazem Kandil * History Today, Best Books of 2024 * A work of immense learning and intellectual ambition -- Mohammad Jashim Uddin * Daily Sun * On picking up and reading Disputing Disaster I was gripped utterly ... What Anderson does in a brief volume - no bad thing - is to give a sweeping account of the writings of all six, but to build on that to point to others he has read on this topic, which is truly extensive, and in an understated way to give us his analysis, delivering in that same understated way, a verdict -- Chris Bambery * Counterfire * Anderson approaches his task with admirable intellectual curiosity and open-mindedness ... a shrewd guide to the often complex and involved political entanglements of the early- and mid-twentieth-century writers. -- T. G. Otte * Times Literary Supplement * Absolutely fascinating . a great addition to an extremely rich field. -- Matthew Stibbe * First World War Studies * Anderson's writing repays reading... a stimulating account of the stakes of the debate. -- William Mulligan * H-Diplo *