The purpose of this book is to investigate with conceptualization how reforms change educational organizations and subjectivities, and how educational organizations change reforms. The book gives an account of the power of conceptual endeavors, with close readings of empirical material.
The book elaborates this through empirical investigations of the intertwinement of different educational reforms, of policies, standards, and everyday educational lives across the globe. As well as telling stories of reforms and how they transform and are transformed by the educational organizations and subjects they engage, the book highlights how a careful enactment of methodologies and critiques might enable a tracing of not only intended but also unintended effects of reforms. In this way, the book explores performative approaches to education reform and thus attempts to nuance the idea of causality and linearity in the implementation of education reforms.
Engaging with performative approaches, this book scrutinizes how reforms are involved with the creation and shaping of the world and thus offers insight into what happens when reforms are borrowed, translated, and taken up in a range of ways. This book was originally published as a special issue of the International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education.
Dorthe Staunæs is Professor in Social Psychology at the Danish School of Education at Aarhus University, Denmark, with a specific focus on subjectivities, diversity and educational leadership/policy. Her qualitative methodologies have contributed significantly to the field of intersectionality and subjectification. Her current work on affirmative critique and data-subjectivities as effects of governance is situated at the intersection of affect studies, queer feminism, black feminism, and new materialism. ORCID: 0000-0002-6554-6632
Katja Brøgger is an Associate Professor at Aarhus University, Denmark. She is the research program director of Policy Futures. Her research on higher education policy and governance explores the relations between transnational reform processes and national policymaking and takes inspiration in 'new materialism'. She is a member of The European Consortium of Political Research, the EU COST Action on New Materialism, the Research Committee at the Danish School of Education, and the Study Board for Education Science. ORCID: 0000-0002-5582-4889
John Benedicto Krejsler is a Professor at Aarhus University, Denmark. His research on new conditions for (pre-)school and teacher education in a transnational perspective brings together education policy, new conditions for producing 'truths', and social technologies. He is the President of the Nordic Educational Research Association and was a council member of the European Educational Research Association (2009-2018). He was a Visiting Professor at Kristianstad University, Sweden (2009-2010), and at UCLA, USA (2015-2016). ORCID: 0000-0002-6471-2723
Introduction - How reforms morph as they move. Performative approaches to education reforms and their un/intended effects
Dorthe Staunæs, Katja Brøgger and John Krejsler
1. The performative power of (non)human agency assemblages of soft governance
2. International large-scale assessments, affective worlds and policy impacts in education
Sam Sellar and Bob Lingard
3. Businesses seeing like a state, governments calculating like a business
4. The 'fear of falling behind regime' embraces school policy: state vs federal policy struggles in California and Texas
John Benedicto Krejsler
5. 'Green with envy:' affects and gut feelings as an affirmative, immanent, and trans-corporeal critique of new motivational data visualizations
6. Reforming time in Danish schools
7. Students of reforms. Investigating and troubling the enactment of student voices in research on reform
Malou Juelskjær, Helene Falkenberg and Vibe Larsen